If Donaire retired today would he be in the hall of fame?

[Larry the boss]

Nonito needs to hold it down at 122 or 126 for a while first. Mares is one guy he definitely needs on his resume.

Mares fight will never happen

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Thoughts???????

I think if he died he would, but if he retired, he wouldn't.

[kiaba360]

Mares fight will never happen

I think Arum should allow Rigo to fight Mares on an GBP card, similar to how GBP allowed Lara to fight Vanes on a TR card. It's possible that Rigo could get the W and Mares would no longer be a factor.

[Larry the boss]

I think Arum should allow Rigo to fight Mares on an GBP card, similar to how GBP allowed Lara to fight Vanes on a TR card. It's possible that Rigo could get the W and Mares would no longer be a factor.

Arum is a peice of **** and will never allow it

[HeroBando]

Donaire has set nothing. Darchinyan, Montiel and Mathebula are his only good wins in 3 weight classes. People mention these names like Hernan Marquez, Sydorenko, Mthalane but these are as good as naming Bruseles, Sosa, Manfredy, Corley, Mitchell for Floyd, it's just reaching.

Unlike most of those names you listed for Floyd, those Donaire opponents had won world titles and defended a number of times. Nishioka whom you haven't listed was Ring #1. Narvaez, still no other losses. Vazquez a better fighter than Ramos, who's Rigo's top 2 win...

[DeadLikeMe]

to me he isn't, but when you look at their standards he probably is

[Angry Cuban]

Unlike most of those names you listed for Floyd, those Donaire opponents had won world titles and defended a number of times. Nishioka whom you haven't listed was Ring #1. Narvaez, still no other losses. Vazquez a better fighter than Ramos, who's Rigo's top 2 win...

Lol..you're crazy..lol

[Angry Cuban]

I think Arum should allow Rigo to fight Mares on an GBP card, similar to how GBP allowed Lara to fight Vanes on a TR card. It's possible that Rigo could get the W and Mares would no longer be a factor.

Mnnn ..very possible..

[HeroBando]

Lol..you're crazy..lol

Everything I wrote was factual except WV2 > Ramos, which is obvious.

[Godsfly]

a key ingredient that donaire is missing is no one on his resume is a hofm'er

who has he beat that could make it in the hall of fame?