Originally posted by hougigo
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Should the state athletic commissions reserve the right to overturn a bogus decision?
Collapse
-
Originally posted by Primera View PostI wouldn't mind it but I think it'd just turn into a popularity contest.
I don't have much to say about Harold Lederman other than his Pacquiao-Bradley scorecard was extremely biased and equally horrible. No way it was even close to 11-1 or 10-2 like he gave it. He must have been listening to Lampley call the fight to produce a scorecard that terrible.
Originally posted by Bushbaby View PostI just love how ts completely left out Pac-Marquez,lol!!
Comment
-
Originally posted by kenso View Postthe State athletic commission could elect a constant "judge board" to reevaluate these bogus decisions.
Originally posted by Roger08 View PostNo the state would end up getting paid off by promoters and become a part of the problem.
Originally posted by Roger08 View Postthey should be allowed to change rediculous decisions to No contests and order rematches however.
Originally posted by Roger08 View Post1. judging criteria needs to change have 5 judges score a fight on ring skill, effective aggresion and defense and give points out of ten for each category so a maximum of 30 points and deduct points if a fighter is knocked down (say 5 points)
We need a simple scoring system that can measure how clearly a fighter won the round. How about this :
If you do just enough to win the round = 1 pt
If you win the round clearly without doing damage = 2pts
If you beat up and hurt your opponent without scoring a knockdown= 3pts
Add one extra point for every knockdown.
Comment
-
Originally posted by hougigo View PostThis is the problem... why do you limit it to high profile?
Oh, it's fine if somebody gets robbed if they don't have a name.......
Another reason is that on the amateur level, usually one guy is clearly better than the other. There aren't that many close fights. On the world class level, these guys are approaching the peak of skill and genetic potential - the skill disparity is much smaller.
Comment
Comment