Carl Froch or Joe Calzaghe? Better resume?

[Left Hook Tua]

Froch the last 2 1/2 years or Calzaghe's ENTIRE career?

Which had the tougher opponents?

Froch the last 2 1/2 years = Jean Pascal , Jermain Taylor , Andre Dirrell , Mikkel Kessler , Arthur Abraham , Glen Johnson

Calzaghe's 15 year career = Chris Eubank , Jeff Lacy , Omar Sheika , Peter Manfredo Jr. , Roy Jones Jr. , Bernard Hopkins


This is a tough one.

[.G.]

you forgot miguel kessler on joes res

[Left Hook Tua]

you forgot miguel kessler on joes res

you're right.


please add miguel kessler for joe.

[Trigg]

you forgot miguel kessler on joes res

Is that Mikkel's Mexican cousin?

[Ko King 212]

Froch hands down.

[DarchinyFAN]

Froch the last 2 1/2 years or Calzaghe's ENTIRE career?

Which had the tougher opponents?

Froch the last 2 1/2 years = Jean Pascal , Jermain Taylor , Andre Dirrell , Mikkel Kessler , Arthur Abraham , Glen Johnson

Calzaghe's 15 year career = Chris Eubank , Jeff Lacy , Omar Sheika , Peter Manfredo Jr. , Roy Jones Jr. , Bernard Hopkins


This is a tough one.

I'd replace Shieka and Manfredo with Reid and Bika

Does make you wonder why Joe didn't try for more in the middle of his career.

[TRAV1$]

Calzaghe
Froch hasn't fought anyone on Hopkins level, and the Kessler that fought Calzaghe is better than anyone Froch has faced
Taylor would've been a great win if hadn't folded late on in so many fights.

[Left Hook Tua]

I'd replace Shieka and Manfredo with Reid and Bika

Does make you wonder why Joe didn't try for more in the middle of his career.

omar sheika was the shit!


add reid to both of them then.

[Left Hook Tua]

Calzaghe
Froch hasn't fought anyone on Hopkins level, and the Kessler that fought Calzaghe is better than anyone Froch has faced.

same kessler.


and after 2 fights , it's obvious jean pascal is on hopkins level.

[gingeralbino]

Joe but Froch is catching up REALLY quickly