Floyd is P4P #2 ever after SRR?

[bravestone]

I agree with this, although only if Basilio was at his very peak.

Kind of unfair considering Mayweather was peak at 135.

[JAB5239]

Bolded fighters are not as great as Mayweather IMO.

I would argue a case for Conn. He has a lot of excellent wins on his resume.

[Barn]

I would argue a case for Conn. He has a lot of excellent wins on his resume.

I don't see it personally but I can see why people do.

[DarkTerror88]

Bolded fighters are not as great as Mayweather IMO.

Fraziers win in FoTC more or less has more weight that 75% of PBFs wins combined

[Andyreww]

sorry nowhere close to srr srl,duran

Mayweather would school duran.

[JAB5239]

I don't see it personally but I can see why people do.

Different strokes. Zivic, Dundee, Yarosz, Corbett III, Apostoli, Bettina, Lesnevich, Pastor, Barlund I think are most notable. More than half of them are HOF fighters, plus I take the first Louis fight into account. That only would be equal to Floyd going to 168 or even 175 and having the same kind of showing against Ward or Dawson.

[Bolo Punch]

Kind of unfair considering Mayweather was peak at 135.

Possbily, although Basilio wasn't exactly a big guy himself, despite actually winning the Middleweight title. A Welterweight Basilio vs. Mayweather is fair, IMO, as Mayweather has been at or around 147 for years now.

[JAB5239]

Mayweather would school duran.

Based on what? Floyd has never fought anyone nearly as complete as Duran.

[SBleeder]

Why stop at #2? Clearly beating Robert Guerrero elevates him to #1 all time. Guerrero would have sparked Robinson in the first round. Too much modern training. If Robinson is so great, why is he dead???

[Bolo Punch]

If Robinson is so great, why is he dead???