How highly do you regard Shane Mosley?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Just out of curiosity, why do you rank Oscar above him?

Because Oscar have More quality wins. Oscar resume is way better. And oscar have more quality opposition than Mosley.

Oscar
at 130-135
Bredahl
Campanella
Paez
Molina
Ruelas
Hernandez
Leija

At 140-147
Chavez x2
Gonzalez
Whitaker
Camacho
Rivera
Quartey
Carr
Trinidad
Mosley
Gatti
Pacquiao

at 154-160
Mosley
Vargas
castillejo
Campas
Sturm
Hopkins
Mayorga
Mayweather


He loses are in bold.

Look at all the top opposition he faced. its not even close in my view!!!!!!

[$partacus]

Not as high as i would if he wasn't a cheat.

[winac]

Better than Pacquiao?
Better than Hopkins?
Better than Mayweather?
Better than Jones?
Better than Trinidad?

Yea the way I see it is how many wins fighters have against great fighters in their prime a fighter has and I think Mosley is up there.

Mosley: De la hoya and Margarito
Trinidad: De la Hoya
Jones: Toney and Hopkins
Pacquiao: Barrera I, Marquez, Morales ( tenuous )
Hopkins: Trinidad, De La hoya, Tarver, Winky, Pavlik

I guess Mosley has big losses so it hurts him but he is certainly up there

[Pullcounter]

An ATG?

yes, but somewhere in the bottom half

Where does he rank in his generation? Which fighters of his generation do you rank above him?

behind the very best: floyd, pac, hopkins, rjj, tito

How much do his losses to Vernon and Winky detract from his resume despite the fact he has many very good and great wins?

depends on if you look at the cup half full or half empty: the fact that mosley didn't win the rematches.

[poontango]

I rank Tito and DLH over him.

In a top 100 ATGs, he should be rank, anythng from 87 to 94!!!!!!!

Tito lost all his big fights and Shane beat DLH twice...so how are they ahead of Shane?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Tito lost all his big fights and Shane beat DLH twice...so how are they ahead of Shane?

Tito lost all his big matches? LMAO

Who lost to 3 bigger men, and 2 he was way out of his prime. GTFO with your nonsense!!!!!!

[poontango]

Tito lost all his big matches? LMAO

Who lost to 3 bigger men, and 2 he was way out of his prime. GTFO with your nonsense!!!!!!

Hopkins, Wright, DelaHoya, Jones...just sayin'

[IMDAZED]

Hopkins, Wright, DelaHoya, Jones...just sayin'

Well he beat Oscar.

And I don't know if you were following the sport then but Vargas was a pretty big win. Actually, nearly every fight from Oscar going was a big win for a period of time.

[MANGLER]

the ATG discussion is always tough in terms of exact placement unless you keep a mental list or some ****. I do think he qualifies to be in there tho. He should be 1-1 against DLH imo, and overall DLH did accomplish more, so I'd put DLH over him. He's done more overall than Forrest and Winky imo, but both beat him twice. Felix lost bad, but late in his run and 2 of em were after long layoffs. I think he's up on SSM also.

[poontango]

Well he beat Oscar.

And I don't know if you were following the sport then but Vargas was a pretty big win. Actually, nearly every fight from Oscar going was a big win for a period of time.

Lol, he may have been given the decision but not because he "beat" Oscar. Oscar gave the fight away. I still remember the look on Tito's face when the decision was announced. He was more than surprised. He knew he got a gift. Despite that decision the public definitely knew who the better fighter was.