With Froch's retirement: Who has the toughest resumes/wins from 2008-2015?

[Showtime..]

Tim Bradley- 10-2 , 1 NC witter, cherry , holt, Campbell, Petersen, abregu, devon, casamayor, Vargas, Mannyx2, ruslan, chaves.

Not a big Tim fan but he deserves credit for this.

Forgot about him wow. Clearly Top 5.

[Chrismart]

JMM's isn't too shabby. Some lower level opponents, some top level and some elite level opponents.
4 losses in that time span, but all very competitive fights bar 1.

[mannyman]

Does the fact that Froch was an underdog in most of those fights make his resume even more impressive???

The other fighters on that list were the favourite in most if not all cases.


What u think?

[CraigM]

I'd say Manny

[soul_survivor]

You should not have mentioned Matthysse at all. His resume from 2008 til present is very poor. Not even top 10.

Amir Khan's resume is also laughable when you put it up against the other fighters of that same span.

Donaire's resume took a turn for the worst, when he started fighting old men and washed up fighters. When he finally stepped up in comp again he has lost to Rigo and Walters.

Donaire faced the best guys in every division he moved into.

Khan has Maidana, Judah, Malignaggi, Kotelnik, Garcia, Alexander, Peterson...all former, future or then world titlists. One is still undefeated, 2 are top 10 welterweights currently and were top 5 light welters then. And so on.

I mentioned Mathysse cos I thought of Garcia, Judah, Alexander and some good second tier guys.

[soul_survivor]

Does the fact that Froch was an underdog in most of those fights make his resume even more impressive???

The other fighters on that list were the favourite in most if not all cases.


What u think?

Good point, it's always more impressive when you win and your not supposed. Also, the manner of victory is very important.