Is James Toney an ATG

[KickAzz]

He's not an all time great but he could have been.

JT wasted his talent

[BUNGALOWS]

JT wasted his talent

If he wasn't eating all day, would we have gotten Toney vs. Jirov/Holyfield/Ruiz/Peter/Rahman/Guinn/Oquendo?

Toney's a beast. Balls of steel.

[Capaedia]

Lower tier ATG

[bojangles1987]

Yes he is, and it's a damn shame that he is getting whipped by bums now.

[Shad0wB0xer]

Hell no! Who has he beat? What division did he dominate?

[Cuban Linx]

Of course he is... although these losses are taking a little hit on his legacy.

[waxfondler]

james toney had top-tier ATG talent... but ultimately didnt live up to full potential... HOF-er no doubt... barely ATG based off of career.

one of my personal favorites

[SlySlickSmooth]

[Bolo Punch]

HOF worthy but not an ATG, IMO.

[PurePugilist216]

How is this is a question? This site shows me you guys really just follow hype and don’t know boxing. James Toney’s resume is on par with Roy Jones and B-Hop. Mccallum twice, Nunn, Holyfield, Jirov, Barkley, 3 division champ and a 4 division champ at one point in his life.

Also might have p4p the best chin of all time, I don’t know many other fighters that went from middle to heavy without being stopped.

He was robbed in the Griffin fights twice

Never ducked anyone

Who has bernard Hopkins beat that makes his resume better then Toneys? Bernard has the longevity achievement but thats about it.

If you don’t believe he’s all time great then I think you guys need to go back and watch the guy