Do you consider Nonito Donaire to be a hall of famer or an all time great

[Unseen]

ATG? Only 1 or 2 will be ATG in our era TBH.

HOF? Well it's much more lineant

[boxinggod101]

idk bro.. he took a atg hof ass whoopin from Rigo.

imo, his resume is weak. the fighters he beat came to lose plus he was much bigger. where is sidorneko now? narvaez? mthlane? not doing ****. and he won a foty award for fighting that weak caliber.

only reason he had any recognition was because 48 coat tail riding.

darch was his biggest win followed by beating an severley overrated montiel.

how overrated was dontcare? he won koty for a knockdown ffs. not a fan of ANY 48ers.

Huh? 48ers? R u that dumb? What a **** post lol

[boxinggod101]

Hof yes he is. ATG only Floyd and Manny and maybe Bhop can be considered.

[PACnPBFsuck]

Easy HOFer, probably won't reach ATG status.

[Pocket Dogs!]

HOF yes. ATG no.

I don't get the hate for Nonito.

The dude fought everybody. When people were telling him to fight Rigo what did he do? He fought Rigo. Today, everybody one or two weight classes above Rigo's weight refuses to fight him, and Nonito is the only person who wants to fight him AGAIN. Most people don't even want to fight Walters and what does Nonito do? He goes up in weight just to challenge him.

[£-4-£]

Bump.

Hall of Fame, without a doubt.

Not ATG.

[CrowsNestWest]

I think he's a HOFer

[Larry the boss]

easily a hall of famer

[BLACK KNOT]

He's a hall of famer for sure. donaire was one the best fighters pound for pound of his era.

[asgarth]

There are a lot of boxers in the HOF who hasnt accomplished what donaire did.

titles at 112, 118, 122, 126.
Unified 118 by beating fellow p4p boxer Fernando Montiel.
Won the ring belt at 122 against Toshiaki Nishioka.
Ring magazine fighter of the year in 2012.

Went down 2 weightclasses at an advance age and won a belt against a decent prime titleholder.

Montiel, Darchinyan, Nishioka, Burnett, Mthalane, Navaez, Hernan Marquez, Vazquez Jr., Mathebula and Arce across 4 weight divisions is decent enough list to get in the HOF.