Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[Cherry Picker]

A lot of people think that Castillo won the first fight with Mayweather and he got robbed. Lederman's card on that night was 115-111 to Castillo. I also think Castillo got robbed. Poll coming up.

[lfc19titles]

he landed around 100 more punches than floyd, everyone bar the crooked judges had castillo winning

[Twako]

castillo. even the whole hbo crew were surprised.

[THE REED]

I personally had it for Castillo and I've watched it countless times. I just didn't feel Floyd did enough work.

[Junito-Rulez]

Castillo won but Floyd is still 41-0. If he was 40-1, he'd already have fought Pacquiao.

[RL_GMA]

I've watched it about 4 times and each time I gave it to Castillo 115-113.

[Mitch5]

he landed around 100 more punches than floyd, everyone bar the crooked judges had castillo winning

I think thats due the rounds castillo clearly won he won big and landed a lot of punches....but the fight was close its not like castillo blew him out floyd won the first 4 rounds clearly to me

[The Big Dunn]

wow. It must really suck when a fighter someone hates wins a close fight with a broken hand (for 7 rds) at a higher weight class. VEry close fight, as close as williams martinez. I thought judges had it right!

[S H A R K B O Y]

If you're going to say Mayweather lost to Castillo the first time around, then you should also be saying Pacquiao lost to Marquez, twice.

[Mitch5]

wow. It must really suck when a fighter someone hates wins a close fight with a broken hand (for 7 rds) at a higher weight class. VEry close fight, as close as williams martinez. I thought judges had it right!

it was a very close fight...but mayweather haters steady claim that castillo beat him down...and floyd really impressed me by fighting through that shoulder injury and fighting castillo his first fight at 135.