Mayweather vs Mosley should be for the Lineal Championship

[Smidgeon]

Originally Posted by Dirt

Right, but pac is #1. Mosley and floyd and 2 and 3 respectively. Guess they nullified cheatos win over cotto or something.

Interesting. Pac's only had one win against a ranked welter in Cotto. Floyd I could understand being at least #3 because he was the lineal champ when he retired and nobody beat it from him, but Pac at #1? That doesn't seem right.

Mosley's inactivity for a long while must have affected his ranking as well, but still.

So at worst, the fight will only be for the WBA belt Mosley holds.

[Filipino Floyd]

Mosley has been out of the ring for so long, Boxrec.com no longer has him listed as an active fighter. They have him listed as retired!

[MakeDamnSure]

No. They have to go through Pacquiao first

[S.G.]

They could certainly make a strong case.

Mayweather was lineal champ and never actually lost the title in a fight, and Mosley beat the man (Margarito) who beat the man (Cotto) who was at the top once Mayweather forfeited his lineal reign.

However I wouldn't complain if they waited until matching up the winner of Mosley-Mayweather with the winner of Pacquiao-Clottey before properly restarting the welterweight lineage.

[markkerr101]

Originally Posted by Stone Roses

how come Pacquiao be the best welterweight in the world???? he fought Cotto at 145 and cotto lost to Margarito, the guy who Shane Mosley demolished.....that makes Mosley the best in the world by way of elmination

Mosley also lost to Cotto. So that makes no sense dude

[crold1]

Originally Posted by IIG

Mayweather is the lineal champ, even though some people might argue Mosley is. Nobody beat Floyd, so how isn't he the lineal champ? This fight is for the lineage period, but The Ring ****ted on Mosley and made Pacquiao the #1 WW. Therefore, no Ring belt.

May is not the lineal champ. He retired and vacated the crown. Just like Joe Gans had to regain the Lightweight title after he vacated it for a short trip to Welter, even though he never lost it in the ring, Floyd has to reseal the deal.

That said, Mosley is (or should be) seen as number one and Floyd, being the last lineal champ, makes this THE fight for the title. For historical backdrop, consider how Ali-Holmes and Louis-Charles each validated the younger man's claim.

Ring's ratings are, IMO, wrong at Welter and Ring isn't the last word on lineage (by a long shot). Beating Cotto in a catchweight bout was not enough to merit #1. Mayweather-Mosley is the thing.

[mrpain81]

In my opinion Mosley/Mayweather will not only determine the true Welterweight Champion but also the P4P king.