If PBF returned and beat Margo, would his greatness be accepted?? - Page 3

ingrando

Antonio Margarito is trash! Since when does somebody get their legacy sealed by beating margarito, in that case Paul Williams already sealed his then...you Margo fans are pathetic. Floyd would have to beat, Oscar De La Hoya rematch, Shane Mosley, Cotto, and last but not least Manny Pacquiao. Then he may be considered the best p4p and his legacy surely would be sealed

adrsan84

Quote:

Originally Posted by ingrando

Antonio Margarito is trash! Since when does somebody get their legacy sealed by beating margarito, in that case Paul Williams already sealed his then...you Margo fans are pathetic. Floyd would have to beat, Oscar De La Hoya rematch, Shane Mosley, Cotto, and last but not least Manny Pacquiao. Then he may be considered the best p4p and his legacy surely would be sealed

The guy you're calling trash has been ducked by DLH, turned down on several occasions by Mosley, knocked Cotto out, and would decapitate Pacquiao. Maybe you don't like him and he may not have the skills that you consider an a top notch boxer, but his resume says otherwise, and he would be a danger to anybody in the ring, far from trash.

Dizzle

i honestly think he needs at LEAST one more big win. ODLH was big name but he was out of his prime. Hatton was not very memorable. PBF should take the fight and prove all the haters wrong....or right haha. But hey, maybe im a little biased because of how much i want to see this happen.

Scott9945

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewz

Arum knows what woulda happened if he put Marg in the ring with Floyd.

Floyd crushed Baldomir. Why would Baldomir Jr. give Floyd any more trouble?

If you think Baldomir was the same level as Margarito, you really need to buy a clue.

Allucard

Quote:

Originally Posted by bearman3000

I was thinking if "money may" came back and stopped Margarito or UD, would he still be criticized for his lack of fighting the best names??? Me personally I would love to see him clear out the welterweight division but if he destroyed and dominated Margo and retired I would be content more then if he didn't fight Margo at all. You????

He will always be criticized no matter what he does... Those types of tipics were made to exhaustion for the Castillo 2, Baldomir, DLH and Hatton fights and those are the ones i remember.

Bad_Barracuda

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewz

Arum knows what woulda happened if he put Marg in the ring with Floyd.

Floyd crushed Baldomir. Why would Baldomir Jr. give Floyd any more trouble?

Plain and basic common sense

Unknown Champ

So pwill or margo will seal the deal with all the complaining from the fans???

Unknown Champ

I think people would be much more content with him beating margo

Flawless

If May beat Margarito and Paul he still be hated on

Unknown Champ

Would you personaly criticize him still?? I would be like he is a bad mutha whether I liked it or not

View Poll Results: Would he be critizced still??
Yes, he needs to clean out the division	26	57.78%
No, if he beat Margo he has beat the best in this division	19	42.22%
Voters: 45. You may not vote on this poll

ingrando Banned Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 91 Rep Power: 0 Points: 9,475.85 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 9,475.85 Donate	Antonio Margarito is trash! Since when does somebody get their legacy sealed by beating margarito, in that case Paul Williams already sealed his then...you Margo fans are pathetic. Floyd would have to beat, Oscar De La Hoya rematch, Shane Mosley, Cotto, and last but not least Manny Pacquiao. Then he may be considered the best p4p and his legacy surely would be sealed

Dizzle Amateur Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 29 Rep Power: 0 Points: 2,483.30 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 2,483.30 Donate	i honestly think he needs at LEAST one more big win. ODLH was big name but he was out of his prime. Hatton was not very memorable. PBF should take the fight and prove all the haters wrong....or right haha. But hey, maybe im a little biased because of how much i want to see this happen.

Unknown Champ Finish Strong Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 4,953 Rep Power: 22 Points: 31,245,026,067.31 Bank: 2,247,803,150,606.58 Total Points: 2,279,048,176,673.89 Donate	So pwill or margo will seal the deal with all the complaining from the fans???

Flawless Banned Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 5,460 Rep Power: 0 Points: 300,297.81 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 300,297.81 Donate	If May beat Margarito and Paul he still be hated on