Better Resume? Donaire or Mares??? - Page 12

HeroBando

Quote:

Originally Posted by deejd

Litzau didn't match Methabula's effort, he eclipsed it; as far as it being ridiculous, no... it's not. Mathebula still lost.

Let me find out that Campbell was a draw. Now I've heard it all. I can't take you seriously.

You haven't seen Mathebula Caba, have you? He should have beaten #1 rated top 10 p4p unified titlist in his hometown. That's one of the best results anyone has had sub feather in years.

Who said Campbell was a draw? Are you denying he was the a side though? Premium networks consistently showed title bouts at LW.

Fighting_Pride

donaire has the better resume

HeroBando

Quote:

Originally Posted by DoktorSleepless

You know, I hadn't seen the Mathebula/Caballero fight before because I couldn't find it. I went by what other people had said about it. I just found it on youtube today and it was it was pretty amazing. An honest to god argument can be made that Mathebula won every single round. Even the Panamanian commentators thought Mathebula won. I personally only gave Caballero the last two rounds when both were tired. There were some competitive rounds that could go either way, but I thought Mathebula edged those rounds too.

It was actually a pretty fun fight and worth watching.

Thanks for posting that. I streamed it live, been trying to track it down for a while. I scored it 8-4 both times, coulda been wider for Jeff. I remember him swarming and frustrating the sh1t out of Caba, but on rewatch he sure dealt out some punishment.

mrlopez

unless you are a hater. Donaire has the better record and has fought better opponents. i like the kid Mares too but i think at this point Nonito is thee man in the division

teddycanyon

Donaire's KO of Darchinyan is probably still the best win of his career. Mares-Darchinyan was a fight that could have gone either way honestly, and Mares fouled Darchy a lot too.
Time will tell how good Moreno can be, I think that win is going to look good in hindsight for Mares. On the surface of it anyway, Donaire's resume I believe is superior at this juncture. Mares's only significant wins are Moreno, Agbeko, Darchinyan (again a big ?) and Morel. Donaire's got a whole bunch of big names: Darchinyan, Narvaez, Nishioka, Montiel, Vazquez Jr., Mthlane, Tyson Marquez, Sidorenko, and Arce.

-BORICUA-

donaire......

AFTER HOURS

Donaire by a little bit

loui_ludwig

Mares has fought good opponents but Donaire still takes it.

Ido

Abner Mares

baya

mares and its not even close.

View Poll Results: Better Resume?
Donaire	76	60.80%
Mares	49	39.20%
Voters: 125. You may not vote on this poll

Fighting_Pride Pure Aggression Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Philippines Posts: 1,239 Blog Entries: 8 Rep Power: 6 Points: 1,080,387.12 Bank: 20,431,284,990.32 Total Points: 20,432,365,377.44 Donate	donaire has the better resume

mrlopez Undisputed Champion Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Sacra, Califas, Aztlan Age: 34 Posts: 2,785 Rep Power: 13 Points: 3,042,052.59 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 3,042,052.59 Donate	its a no brainer unless you are a hater. Donaire has the better record and has fought better opponents. i like the kid Mares too but i think at this point Nonito is thee man in the division

-BORICUA- Matthysse will KO Garcia Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 4,554 Rep Power: 13 Points: 25,680,264,603.83 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 25,680,264,603.83 Donate	donaire......

AFTER HOURS Paul Hackett Join Date: Sep 2008 Posts: 1,927 Rep Power: 8 Points: 1,000,076,564.74 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,000,076,564.74 Donate	Donaire by a little bit

loui_ludwig Undisputed Champion Join Date: Oct 2005 Age: 26 Posts: 7,603 Rep Power: 28 Points: 291,162.17 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 291,162.17 Donate	Mares has fought good opponents but Donaire still takes it.

Ido Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Chicago Posts: 1,390 Rep Power: 7 Points: 100,075,506.81 Bank: 93,998.46 Total Points: 100,169,505.27 Donate	Abner Mares

baya Trinidad was a BUM Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: DC *****es, top of the food chain! Posts: 8,853 Rep Power: 137 Points: 211,070,224,536.51 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 211,070,224,536.51 Donate	mares and its not even close.