Who will be remembered as the greater fighter..

Earl Hickey

When their carrers are over.

This is a replication of a poll on the ring website, that has shocking results.

G22

Holyfield or Jones IMO.

What were the shocking results of the other poll?

Earl Hickey

Quote:

Originally Posted by G22

Holyfield or Jones IMO.

What were the shocking results of the other poll?

Pacquiao 1, mayweather 2 and marquez 3

Simurgh

Jones, although both him and Holyfield screwed it up by not retiring on time.

G22

Quote:

Pacquiao 1, mayweather 2 and marquez 3

Im guessing the voters in that poll had only been following the sport for a couple years

damuttz112

I hope Holyfield, he's achieved more than any other fighter there.

Earl Hickey

Quote:

Originally Posted by G22

Holyfield or Jones IMO.

What were the shocking results of the other poll?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Simurgh

Jones, although both him and Holyfield screwed it up by not retiring on time.

I got Holyfield 1 and Jones 2

Holyfield the greater wins imo, and would win H2H at 175 imo

Jones not far behind, then Hopkins/Marquez/Pac/May not much between them

Capaedia

Now that I've voted, probably Holyfield based mainly on him being a heavyweight. Especially a heavyweight who knocked out Mike Tyson.

But I voted for Jones

G22

Quote:

I got Holyfield 1 and Jones 2

Holyfield the greater wins imo, and would win H2H at 175 imo

Jones not far behind, then Hopkins/Marquez/Pac/May not much between them

I agree. You can pretty much ignore the last 10 years of Evanders career and it still doesnt affect his ranking.

D-MiZe

Holyfield doesn't compare to likes of Pac achievement wise. He's the GOAT at 200lbs but Pac is unparalleled with what he's done.

View Poll Results: vote
Evander Holyfield	16	18.18%
Roy Jones	18	20.45%
Bernard Hopkins	6	6.82%
Floyd Mayweather	19	21.59%
Manny Pacquiao	26	29.55%
Juan Manuel Marquez	3	3.41%
Shane Mosley	0	0%
Voters: 88. You may not vote on this poll

Earl Hickey jason bruce lee Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 16,253 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 97 Points: 52,000.73 Bank: 5,842,235,297,726.19 Total Points: 5,842,235,349,726.92 Donate	Who will be remembered as the greater fighter.. When their carrers are over. This is a replication of a poll on the ring website, that has shocking results.

G22 Contender Join Date: Dec 2012 Posts: 207 Rep Power: 1 Points: 3,494.27 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 3,494.27 Donate	Holyfield or Jones IMO. What were the shocking results of the other poll?

Simurgh Undisputed Champion Join Date: Feb 2012 Posts: 1,584 Rep Power: 5 Points: 2,038,045,053.82 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 2,038,045,053.82 Donate	Jones, although both him and Holyfield screwed it up by not retiring on time.

damuttz112 Interim Champion Join Date: Mar 2012 Posts: 783 Rep Power: 5 Points: 42,184.38 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 42,184.38 Donate	I hope Holyfield, he's achieved more than any other fighter there.

Capaedia JMM Stan Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Auckland, New Zealand Posts: 2,660 Rep Power: 16 Points: 143,850,501,446.86 Bank: 1,522,464,202.26 Total Points: 145,372,965,649.12 Donate	Now that I've voted, probably Holyfield based mainly on him being a heavyweight. Especially a heavyweight who knocked out Mike Tyson. But I voted for Jones

D-MiZe Iron lungs Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: England Posts: 28,809 Blog Entries: 7 Rep Power: 86 Points: 2,007,496,931,692.93 Bank: 989,944,221,932.50 Total Points: 2,997,441,153,625.43 Donate	Holyfield doesn't compare to likes of Pac achievement wise. He's the GOAT at 200lbs but Pac is unparalleled with what he's done.