Your thoughts on Sergio Martinez

[IronDanHamza]

Originally Posted by NearHypnos

Macklin and Jr dominant wins is a DAMN good year. :|

Chavez Jr was a good win.

Macklin, Barker and now Murray, average fights, at best.

Poor for a Top P4P fighter, in all honesty.

[hurtbizness83]

A beast and one of my favorite boxers to watch

[SnakeVen0m]

Originally Posted by IronDanHamza

Chavez Jr was a good win.

Macklin, Barker and now Murray, average fights, at best.

Poor for a Top P4P fighter, in all honesty.

People keep saying that, but who else was better at the time in that division? Those are solid wins and those guys will probably go on to beat other good fighters.

[GoldSugar]

Originally Posted by IronDanHamza

Chavez Jr was a good win.

Macklin, Barker and now Murray, average fights, at best.

Poor for a Top P4P fighter, in all honesty.

Well not many P4p guys fought murderers row opposition. The #1 guy beat Ortiz and Cotto.

[Tom Cruise]

Originally Posted by IronDanHamza

Chavez Jr was a good win.

Macklin, Barker and now Murray, average fights, at best.

Poor for a Top P4P fighter, in all honesty.

Who else should he have fought though?

Hes too small to move up and despite what he says i think he would struggle to move down.

GGG is probably the best at the moment but hes only just come on the scene properly.

As long as he keeps knocking them out, and aslong as when a challenge comes along he doesnt duck it, i dont mind too much.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Don't understand why anybody knocks the Macklin win. Macklin is a good fighter, deserves his high ranking in the division and was coming off a world title fight most people feel he won...that really should have been a champion vs champion fight.

[IronDanHamza]

Originally Posted by SnakeVen0m

People keep saying that, but who else was better at the time in that division? Those are solid wins and those guys will probably go on to beat other good fighters.

Well anyone in the Top 20 would have been better than Darren Barker.

Macklin was a solid win considering he should have got the decision against Sturm but It's hard to say he was the best option out there.

Martin Murray yet another obvious joke of a fight.

[IronDanHamza]

Originally Posted by GoldSugar

Well not many P4p guys fought murderers row opposition. The #1 guy beat Ortiz and Cotto.

Well, both Ortiz and Cotto are much better wins than the likes of Macklin, Barker and Murray.

[hobojo]

late bloomer. hopefully he still keeps his athletecism so he can continue fightin top dog opponants. if he does fight ggg and wins he should retire or canelo if he goes to 160.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Jloro]

Originally Posted by IronDanHamza

Well, both Ortiz and Cotto are much better wins than the likes of Macklin, Barker and Murray.

Macklin's not bad didn't he just get a first round ko not too long ago? I don't really know anything about the other two