Does Mayweather Jr deserve the p4p #1 spot?

SirTomJones

In the past 9 years this is who Floyd has fought.

2003 (2 fights)
Victoriano Sosa
Phillip Ndou

2004 (1 fight)
DeMarcus Corley

2005 (3 fights)
Henry Bruseles
Arturo Gatti
Sharmba Mitchell

2006 (2 fights)
Zab Judah
Carlos Manuel Baldomir

2007 (2 fights and arguably his best year)
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton

2008 (no fights)

2009 (1 fight)
Juan Manuel Marquez

2010 (1fight)
Shane Mosley

2011 (1fight)
Victor Ortiz

2012 (1fight)
Miguel Cotto

only 4 fights since Hatton in 2007.

01samuelc

No p4p is for fighters. Floyd at this stage of his career is in the entertainment/event business (wwf/wwe)

Money Team.

Ward should be #1

Rip Chudd

Quote:

Originally Posted by MR. LARRYX

Ward should be #1

I have him at #1 on my list

KRAFTSMAN

Like I always say inactivity is tantamount to ducking, avoiding fights, taking less risks, fear of losing, protecting the zero, you name it. Do the math. A guy who fights less often have more chances of maintaining the status... This is not rocket science.

DeadLikeMe

Ward has been my #1 since after Froch. Floyd/Sergio/JMM fill out the next 4 (any order I could see arguments for). Donaire and Pac in 5/6 (a win over Arce would move Donaire up into the next bracket)...7/8 Wlad/Bradley...then there are a bunch of guys who you could give those last 2 spots to.

The Weebler II

To get the No.1 spot FMJ should rematch Marquez at 144.

And I don't want to see Flomos saying he can't make the weight, his own father and uncle say he could make 140 never mind 144.

If he's not prepared to move down then fight Martinez at 154 or Pacquiao at 147.

Otherwise he can't be in the discussion, a fighter who doesn't want to take on the best can't be considered the best.

DeadLikeMe

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Weebler II

To get the No.1 spot FMJ should rematch Marquez at 144.

And I don't want to see Flomos saying he can't make the weight, his own father and uncle say he could make 140 never mind 144.

If he's not prepared to move down then fight Martinez at 154 or Pacquiao at 147.

Otherwise he can't be in the discussion, a fighter who doesn't want to take on the best can't be considered the best.

Pac fights Marquez at 147 twice and this simpleton declares Floyd must fight Marquez at 144.

SirTomJones

Ward pretty much has it in the bag doesn't he?

Since 2009 Miranda, Kessler, Green, Bika , Abraham, Froch and Dawson. The boy has been busy.

Biolink

Voted yes, but then thought of Ward.

View Poll Results: Is he p4p #1?
Yes	41	38.32%
No	66	61.68%
Voters: 107. You may not vote on this poll

01samuelc Contender Join Date: Feb 2009 Age: 23 Posts: 458 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 0 Points: 170,438.30 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 170,438.30 Donate	No p4p is for fighters. Floyd at this stage of his career is in the entertainment/event business (wwf/wwe)

Money Team. Banned Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: Getting Money Posts: 27,558 Rep Power: 188 Points: 570,000,347,571.49 Bank: 69,713,196,433,735.91 Total Points: 70,283,196,781,307.40 Donate	Ward should be #1

KRAFTSMAN Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2011 Posts: 1,637 Rep Power: 7 Points: 16,546.06 Bank: 14,479,930,761.66 Total Points: 14,479,947,307.72 Donate	Like I always say inactivity is tantamount to ducking, avoiding fights, taking less risks, fear of losing, protecting the zero, you name it. Do the math. A guy who fights less often have more chances of maintaining the status... This is not rocket science.

DeadLikeMe don't poke the badger Join Date: Dec 2011 Posts: 4,985 Rep Power: 49 Points: 1,896,633,822.05 Bank: 944,498,918,670.68 Total Points: 946,395,552,492.73 Donate	Ward has been my #1 since after Froch. Floyd/Sergio/JMM fill out the next 4 (any order I could see arguments for). Donaire and Pac in 5/6 (a win over Arce would move Donaire up into the next bracket)...7/8 Wlad/Bradley...then there are a bunch of guys who you could give those last 2 spots to.

The Weebler II Floyd Mayweather 4 Ever! Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 13,514 Rep Power: 36 Points: 21,336,538,526.85 Bank: 12,839,065.39 Total Points: 21,349,377,592.24 Donate	To get the No.1 spot FMJ should rematch Marquez at 144. And I don't want to see Flomos saying he can't make the weight, his own father and uncle say he could make 140 never mind 144. If he's not prepared to move down then fight Martinez at 154 or Pacquiao at 147. Otherwise he can't be in the discussion, a fighter who doesn't want to take on the best can't be considered the best.

SirTomJones !!!Flash!!! Join Date: Jun 2008 Posts: 16,269 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 71 Points: 32,647,885,593.35 Bank: 11,478,672,701,845.40 Total Points: 11,511,320,587,438.75 Donate	Ward pretty much has it in the bag doesn't he? Since 2009 Miranda, Kessler, Green, Bika , Abraham, Froch and Dawson. The boy has been busy.

Biolink Donaire is #1 Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Chicago,Illinois Age: 23 Posts: 5,911 Rep Power: 20 Points: 4,441,999,576.07 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 4,441,999,576.07 Donate	Voted yes, but then thought of Ward.