LOTR VS Harry Potter... which is better?

TensionKiller

Which one do you prefer and why?

Love LOTR, just starting HP film 1 now. Let's see what the hype is all about!

Of course I hear the books are both superb, however I have really bad concentration so find it difficult to read a whole book.

Terrel

LOTR and it's not even close.

jose830

saw the first Harry Potter when it came out and I thought it was garbage, LOTR is by far a better movie.

talip bin osman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terrel

LOTR and it's not even close.

yup...

and thats only LOTR we are talking about...

we are excluding the silmarillion and the hobbit here...

naaaah, theres no contest...

TensionKiller

But have you guts seen every HP? I have been told to watch each one.

Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Terrel

Quote:

Originally Posted by talip bin osman

yup...

and thats only LOTR we are talking about...

we are excluding the silmarillion and the hobbit here...

naaaah, theres no contest...

I'm a huge fan of the trilogy.

They stuck to the book well and are so detailed in many of the scenes. It's just an awesome movie. Well done to Mr Jackson. you checked up on the early reviews for The Hobbit?

Not looking too good. Too long according to many. Though, the effects in 3D and overall action have been given a thumbs up.

Terrel

Quote:

Originally Posted by Saracen

But have you guts seen every HP? I have been told to watch each one.

Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

I've seen them all. It's not a sh*t movie (IMO) but it ain't no LOTR.

Sake1

I have never seen either. I say I don't like those types of movies but I've never gave 'em a chance. One day.

talip bin osman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terrel

I'm a huge fan of the trilogy.

They stuck to the book well and are so detailed in many of the scenes. It's just an awesome movie. Well done to Mr Jackson. you checked up on the early reviews for The Hobbit?

Not looking too good. Too long according to many. Though, the effects in 3D and overall action have been given a thumbs up.

thats a problem with peter jackson's style...

he loves to lengthen ****... for the geek side of us thats fine... but for the rest its hit or miss...

iLovesoccermoms

Big fan of both here [huge dork i am]

i wouldnt even Compare that walkathon to Harry Potter..

Not even close, all 8 Potter movies are Awesome, older fans will always choose LOTR obviously and it has cool special effects etc Potter films are just that...Better Filming and i wouldnt even question this..

None of u guys have seen probably more than one Potter Movie and even if u did it was years ago anyways, Potter series is probably The Greatest Franchise of all time, i know how u guys hate me for saying that but its true..

View Poll Results: Which do you think is better?
Lord of the Ring	43	93.48%
Harry Potter	3	6.52%
Voters: 46. You may not vote on this poll

TensionKiller Banned Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 1,533 Rep Power: 0 Points: 32,422.89 Bank: 811,140,039,100.71 Total Points: 811,140,071,523.60 Donate	LOTR VS Harry Potter... which is better? Which one do you prefer and why? Love LOTR, just starting HP film 1 now. Let's see what the hype is all about! Of course I hear the books are both superb, however I have really bad concentration so find it difficult to read a whole book.

Terrel Banned Join Date: May 2010 Location: Birmingham, UK Age: 26 Posts: 6,469 Rep Power: 82 Points: 8,906,581.12 Bank: 856,655.97 Total Points: 9,763,237.09 Donate	LOTR and it's not even close.

jose830 New Jersey Drive Join Date: Mar 2012 Posts: 14,338 Rep Power: 143 Points: 64,844,841.36 Bank: 117,244,671,120,000.23 Total Points: 117,244,735,964,841.59 Donate	saw the first Harry Potter when it came out and I thought it was garbage, LOTR is by far a better movie.

Sake1 Interim Champion Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 718 Rep Power: 2 Points: 7,856.14 Bank: 16,828,183,474.31 Total Points: 16,828,191,330.45 Donate	I have never seen either. I say I don't like those types of movies but I've never gave 'em a chance. One day.