Could a 250 lb man no fights exp beat a 130 lb man who boxed 3 years

TensionKiller

What do you guys think?

130 is quite small, he is 5 foot 8. Had many fights and boxes for 4 years but not pro.

250 lb man is 6 foot 2, does weight lifting. Never had a fight in his life.

Konstantin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Saracen

What do you guys think?

130 is quite small, he is 5 foot 8. Had many fights and boxes for 4 years but not pro.

250 lb man is 6 foot 2, does weight lifting. Never had a fight in his life.

3 years experience isn't very descriptive. I've learned more guitar in my last 2 years of playing than in the previous 5 years...

TensionKiller

Quote:

Originally Posted by Konstantin

3 years experience isn't very descriptive. I've learned more guitar in my last 2 years of playing than in the previous 5 years...

That is true, but can the size advantage mean the 139lber punch won't hurt him? Is his height also too much?

Let's just say, the man has had 30 amateur fights. He goes gym 3 times a week for 2 hours a go.

AntonTheMeh

only if the 250 pound man has a 100 inch reach, has an afro, and wears the same size shoes that adrien broner does.

Sin City

how extensive is his amateur background?
sometimes size doesn't matter when there is skill involved.

have you ever seen the Pros vs Joes with Arturo Gatti beating up regular Joes? I think some of them were upwards of 200 lbs.

Sin City

****E

Arturo Gatti Beatdown

Sin City

boxingscene won't let me post.. just replace the stars with s p i k

http://www.****e.com/video-clips/agv...gatti-beatdown

TensionKiller

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sin City

how extensive is his amateur background?
sometimes size doesn't matter when there is skill involved.

have you ever seen the Pros vs Joes with Arturo Gatti beating up regular Joes? I think some of them were upwards of 200 lbs.

I saw that video, but they looked soft IMO. Not only physically, but they looked like not alpha males. Gatti also looked 155 lbs there and is a pro LOL.

30 amateur fights. Not too much but enough. Generally fit shape.

What is the barrier when size isn't important?

jose830

is it a street fight?

Sin City

Quote:

Originally Posted by Saracen

I saw that video, but they looked soft IMO. Not only physically, but they looked like not alpha males. Gatti also looked 155 lbs there and is a pro LOL.

30 amateur fights. Not too much but enough. Generally fit shape.

What is the barrier when size isn't important?

someone with 30 amateur fights knows his craft fairly well.. you forget that it's also 3-4 years of sparring for those amateur fights.

erik morales didn't look like an 'alpha male' but was a beast.. muscle sometimes doesn't mean a thing.

TensionKiller Banned Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 1,533 Rep Power: 0 Points: 32,312.89 Bank: 811,140,039,100.71 Total Points: 811,140,071,413.60 Donate	Could a 250 lb man no fights exp beat a 130 lb man who boxed 3 years What do you guys think? 130 is quite small, he is 5 foot 8. Had many fights and boxes for 4 years but not pro. 250 lb man is 6 foot 2, does weight lifting. Never had a fight in his life.

AntonTheMeh D'yer Mak'er bobsled team Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 19,972 Rep Power: 53 Points: 1,000,041,310.56 Bank: 4,349,333,096.17 Total Points: 5,349,374,406.73 Donate	only if the 250 pound man has a 100 inch reach, has an afro, and wears the same size shoes that adrien broner does.

Sin City la mala vida Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Las Vegas Posts: 29,720 Rep Power: 123 Points: 444,165,788.00 Bank: 14,882,448,580.96 Total Points: 15,326,614,368.96 Donate	how extensive is his amateur background? sometimes size doesn't matter when there is skill involved. have you ever seen the Pros vs Joes with Arturo Gatti beating up regular Joes? I think some of them were upwards of 200 lbs.

jose830 New Jersey Drive Join Date: Mar 2012 Posts: 14,295 Rep Power: 143 Points: 64,844,541.97 Bank: 114,945,756,000,000.23 Total Points: 114,945,820,844,542.22 Donate	is it a street fight?