Does Floyd make your top 50 list - Page 4

oc9979

In my opinion Top 25

jayjames616

Floyd is top 50 easily, top 20 probably and top 10 arguably.

Blue_Ghost

Top 5 atg great list..If he beats Pac it want be a debate.

IronDanHamza

Well, he beat four, yes FOUR 100% HOF'ers and obviously barely anyone has done that so I'd say he's atleast Top 2.

-MAKAVELLI-

i have him at #216 on my list...behind Tony Lopez

Imatroll

The guy never took risks. He retired during his prime and returned only to fight only once a year. That weighs in a ton on my decision. Probably between 60-70

DTMB

his best win is diego corrales. someone who probably wont make the hall of fame. What's his second and third best wins?

Ricky Hatton at 147? Past prime oscar at 154? late 30s shane who was off for a year and a half yet managed to almost KHTFO? Castillo who beat him the first time?

he has yet TO FACE a LEGIT PRIME HALL OF FAMER.

How much is that greatness worth in ATG rankings?

bojangles1987

Quote:

Originally Posted by -MAKAVELLI-

i have him at #216 on my list...behind Tony Lopez

Look at this nuthugger...

Floyd doesn't exactly have a bunch of world beaters to his credit, but the names he has are good enough that with his ability, he should be top 50 IMO.

RapidFire_Royce

For those who place him outside of the top 50 I would be interested to see their complete top 50 list with explanation. Just to see how many saying this are legit vs just dont like him.

Roja's480

Floyd 30-40
Pac 40-50

both great fighters

View Poll Results: Where does Floyd rank in the top 50 ATGs?
He earned a spot in the top 10 at #10	13	20.63%
Just outside the top 10, probably 11-20	8	12.70%
Around 21-30	9	14.29%
I'd put him between 31-39	8	12.70%
Maybe 40-49	9	14.29%
He barely makes it at #50	16	25.40%
Voters: 63. You may not vote on this poll

oc9979 Bad Intentions Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Jax, Fl Age: 26 Posts: 6,960 Rep Power: 18 Points: 224,822,018.33 Bank: 16,557,025,117.50 Total Points: 16,781,847,135.83 Donate	In my opinion Top 25

jayjames616 Interim Champion Join Date: Jan 2012 Posts: 789 Rep Power: 3 Points: 55,844.91 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 55,844.91 Donate	Floyd is top 50 easily, top 20 probably and top 10 arguably.

Blue_Ghost Amateur Join Date: Oct 2012 Posts: 2 Rep Power: 0 Points: 228.32 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 228.32 Donate	Top 5 atg great list..If he beats Pac it want be a debate.

IronDanHamza All Time Great Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 17,604 Rep Power: 47 Points: 262,340,571.09 Bank: 1,591,748,952,534.75 Total Points: 1,592,011,293,105.84 Donate	Well, he beat four, yes FOUR 100% HOF'ers and obviously barely anyone has done that so I'd say he's atleast Top 2.

-MAKAVELLI- The 5th Horseman Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 47,143 Rep Power: 265 Points: 21,094,196.84 Bank: 45,554,549,555,605.30 Total Points: 45,554,570,649,802.14 Donate	i have him at #216 on my list...behind Tony Lopez

Imatroll Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 2,147 Rep Power: 11 Points: 100,187,643.20 Bank: 214,126,769.93 Total Points: 314,314,413.13 Donate	The guy never took risks. He retired during his prime and returned only to fight only once a year. That weighs in a ton on my decision. Probably between 60-70

DTMB NSB War Veteran Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 3,027 Rep Power: 16 Points: 910,916.68 Bank: 16,266,995,197.79 Total Points: 16,267,906,114.47 Donate	his best win is diego corrales. someone who probably wont make the hall of fame. What's his second and third best wins? Ricky Hatton at 147? Past prime oscar at 154? late 30s shane who was off for a year and a half yet managed to almost KHTFO? Castillo who beat him the first time? he has yet TO FACE a LEGIT PRIME HALL OF FAMER. How much is that greatness worth in ATG rankings?

RapidFire_Royce Contender Join Date: Nov 2007 Age: 29 Posts: 312 Rep Power: 0 Points: 31,050.89 Bank: 37,688,926.34 Total Points: 37,719,977.23 Donate	For those who place him outside of the top 50 I would be interested to see their complete top 50 list with explanation. Just to see how many saying this are legit vs just dont like him.

Roja's480 What The Ph*k Join Date: Dec 2010 Posts: 2,161 Rep Power: 7 Points: 1,616,038,981.85 Bank: 170,014,172.65 Total Points: 1,786,053,154.50 Donate	Floyd 30-40 Pac 40-50 both great fighters