Mayweather/Castillio 1 or Pacquiao/JMM 3, which fight was closer?

cixthree

Vote please

Money Team.

Well Floyd won a comfortable ud in his first fight at 135 against a big lw.....Manny won a split decision against a 38 year old lightweight who had won 0 fights at ww

TX_BOXNG

moneymay vs castillo, pac vs jmm i had it 8-4

Boxing Bob

all 3 of the Pac/JMM fights were closer than Floyd/Cotto

jayjames616

I voted mayweather vs castillio. This fight was very close in my eyes and could have went either way. The Manny vs JMM fight was a clear JMM win.

SCEN3RY · 05:57 PM

and so begins the battle of the alts

oddly asked though, I mean I admit I scrutinized pac vs jmm 3 A LOT more carefully because of the backlash in terms of the magnitude of the fight, but I found a clear winner in both bouts...I'm actually glad you asked this, I think I owe mayweather-castillo more viewing. (I voted mayweather-castillo btw...I basically had it like a round closer)

zcm

If the mayweather/Castillo fight was scored 7/5 either way I wouldnt have argued with the scoring, but I felt Marquez won the PAC fight 7/5 at the worst (I had it 8/4).

GrandpaBernard

May-Castillo

Juan gave pacquiao a boxing lesson in their trilogy

josenoway

jlc-fmj 1.

ADP02

Quote:

Originally Posted by larryx2012

Well Floyd won a comfortable ud in his first fight at 135 against a big lw.....Manny won a split decision against a 38 year old lightweight who had won 0 fights at ww

You are quick to point out that Marquez hadn't won at WW .... that is kind of a weird statement coming from a Floyd fan.

At least Manny vs Marquez had a rivalry, what's Floyd's excuse for taking on these fighters?

Floyd fought at WW:
Marquez who had 0 fights at WW

Hatton who had 1 recent fight at WW but went back down for 2 after that performance .....hmmm..... lol

Ortiz who had 1 fight at WW and went life and death .... has a 1-2 record at WW now.

Sharmba who had 1 fight at WW ......

Khan who had 0 fights at WW but was supposed to be Floyd's next fight but a JWW changed that.

Judah who lost frequently at WW, including the fight prior to Floyd's against a very average fighter (Baldomir) and who finally decided that he doesn't belong at WW and went back down to 140!

View Poll Results: Which fight was closer?
Mayweather/Castillio 1 was closer	34	60.71%
JMM/Manny 3 was closer	22	39.29%
Voters: 56. You may not vote on this poll

cixthree Banned Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 2,227 Rep Power: 0 Points: 330,450.25 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 330,450.25 Donate	Mayweather/Castillio 1 or Pacquiao/JMM 3, which fight was closer? Vote please

Money Team. Banned Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: Getting Money Posts: 27,558 Rep Power: 188 Points: 570,000,351,156.49 Bank: 69,713,196,433,735.91 Total Points: 70,283,196,784,892.40 Donate	Well Floyd won a comfortable ud in his first fight at 135 against a big lw.....Manny won a split decision against a 38 year old lightweight who had won 0 fights at ww

TX_BOXNG Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: TEJAZTLAN Posts: 2,446 Rep Power: 8 Points: 5,170,025,197.62 Bank: 14,012,131,538.24 Total Points: 19,182,156,735.86 Donate	moneymay vs castillo, pac vs jmm i had it 8-4

Boxing Bob Mexico = GOAT :mexico1: Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 1,308 Rep Power: 0 Points: 5,027,334.55 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 5,027,334.55 Donate	all 3 of the Pac/JMM fights were closer than Floyd/Cotto

jayjames616 Interim Champion Join Date: Jan 2012 Posts: 790 Rep Power: 3 Points: 55,911.37 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 55,911.37 Donate	I voted mayweather vs castillio. This fight was very close in my eyes and could have went either way. The Manny vs JMM fight was a clear JMM win.

zcm Contender Join Date: May 2009 Location: Birmingham Posts: 413 Rep Power: 5 Points: 102,035,566.16 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 102,035,566.16 Donate	If the mayweather/Castillo fight was scored 7/5 either way I wouldnt have argued with the scoring, but I felt Marquez won the PAC fight 7/5 at the worst (I had it 8/4).

GrandpaBernard motherfuc Join Date: May 2010 Posts: 3,902 Rep Power: 0 Points: 54,045,829.77 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 54,045,829.77 Donate	May-Castillo Juan gave pacquiao a boxing lesson in their trilogy

josenoway Undisputed Champion Join Date: May 2005 Age: 43 Posts: 2,198 Rep Power: 13 Points: 2,100,026,561.12 Bank: 2,223,816.71 Total Points: 2,102,250,377.83 Donate	jlc-fmj 1.