who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker - Page 2

Andyreww

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTMB

azumah nelson, buddy mcgirt, paez, and absolutely freaking on a undefeated julio cesar chavez >>>>>>>>>>> anybody on floyd's resume.

Azumah nelson and buddy mcgirt rofl..

Money Team.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTMB

azumah nelson, buddy mcgirt, paez, and absolutely freaking on a undefeated julio cesar chavez >>>>>>>>>>> anybody on floyd's resume.

i disagree man floyds resume is deeper and he has accomplished alot more

DTMB

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andyreww

Floyd, he sparred with whittaker when he was around 17 and won.

lots of sparring partners beat muhammad ali in sparring. it doesnt mean anything. its sparring. lots of great fighters dont take sparring seriously. they use it to get work in. only imbeciles of the highest order would make your point.

DTMB

Quote:

Originally Posted by larryx2013

i disagree man floyds resume is deeper and he has accomplished alot more

how is floyd's resume better when he has yet to face a legit prime hall of fame fighter?

DempseyRollin

its whitaker imo

Money Team.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTMB

how is floyd's resume better when he has yet to face a legit prime hall of fame fighter?

hall of famers on his resume
cotto-champ
oscar-champ
mosley-champ
castillo-champ
corrales
hatton-
jmm

4Corners

Depends on what happens in the future.

There's a very good chance that on top of De La Hoya, Mosley, Marquez, and Cotto being in the HOF one day, fighters like Genaro, Corrales, Castillo, and even Hatton have a shot at possibly getting on someday.

DTMB

Quote:

Originally Posted by larryx2013

hall of famers on his resume
cotto-champ
oscar-champ
mosley-champ
castillo-champ
corrales
hatton-
jmm

castillo is not getting in. best believe that. corrales is a long shot. hatton due to his popularity. Cotto is iffy.

JMM-PAST PRIME
MOSLEY-CMON SON. PAST PRIME
OSCAR-PAST PRIME

Again,

name me a bona fide without doubt hall of famer that floyd beat that was in their prime.

4Corners

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTMB

castillo is not getting in. best believe that. corrales is a long shot. hatton due to his popularity. Cotto is iffy.

JMM-PAST PRIME
MOSLEY-CMON SON. PAST PRIME
OSCAR-PAST PRIME

Again,

name me a bona fide without doubt hall of famer that floyd beat that was in their prime.

Castillo has a shot to get in eventually man. Best LW of his era, 2x LW champ, wins over Bazan-Johnston-Lazcano-Diaz-Corrales-Casamayor, and he very well could have had a win over Floyd.

Corrales also has a shot eventually as well. 4x champ in 2 weight class, wins over Garcia-Manfredy-Gainer-Casamayor-Freitas-Castillo.

Hatton has a shot as well. 3x champ in 2 weight class, wins over Tszyu-Urango-Maussa-Lazcano-Malignaggi, the Tszyu win helps him a lot. Even though Tszyu was past his prime-still good, he was still #3 P4P and the linael JWW champ when Hatton beat him.

Mosley and Oscar were past their prime but they were still good fights at those times. Oscar was a Top SWW, the only legit title holder there other then Spinks. And Mosley was #3 P4P, WBA WW champ, and one of the top 1-2 WW's after he beat Margarito down. He was considered the man at 147 when Floyd fought him.

And Marquez was past his prime-still good, and arguably just beat Manny at the same weight. Floyd should get some props for that, and Marquez was #2 P4P at the time. Not an ATG win or anything, but a solid/good win for sure now that he proved he can fight well at that weight.

Cardinal Buck

^You're shorting Genero here. I give him a better chance of making the hall of fame than Castillo.

View Poll Results: who ranks higher
floyd	85	43.59%
Whitaker	110	56.41%
Voters: 195. You may not vote on this poll

DempseyRollin Trolling 24/7 Join Date: Mar 2010 Posts: 11,503 Rep Power: 31 Points: 3,106,266,469.45 Bank: 3,478,758,096.79 Total Points: 6,585,024,566.24 Donate	its whitaker imo

4Corners Desert Eagle Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Colorado Posts: 11,087 Rep Power: 32 Points: 200,105,553,426.11 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 200,105,553,426.11 Donate	Depends on what happens in the future. There's a very good chance that on top of De La Hoya, Mosley, Marquez, and Cotto being in the HOF one day, fighters like Genaro, Corrales, Castillo, and even Hatton have a shot at possibly getting on someday.

Cardinal Buck Undisputed Champion Join Date: Nov 2011 Posts: 1,337 Rep Power: 5 Points: 1,000,032,912.73 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,000,032,912.73 Donate	^You're shorting Genero here. I give him a better chance of making the hall of fame than Castillo.