Carl Froch or Joe Calzaghe? Better resume?

[RichCCFC]

It's not hard to find the boxing newbs (No_Ceiling + wazza)

[Left Hook Tua]

Originally Posted by RichCCFC

It's not hard to find the boxing newbs (No_Ceiling + wazza)

i don't think they realize how good guys like byron mitchell , robin reid , charles brewer , omar sheika , etc. was back then.

they were highly ranked and ranked for several years.

they're just not known names.

[RichCCFC]

Yep and before he won the title he fought nobody!

[RichCCFC]

Hopkins>>Pascal
Eubank>Taylor
Kessler>Dirrell
Lacy = Abraham
Bika>Magee
Jones
Mitchell
Brewer
Woodhall
Reid
Veit

Really it's a whitewash and if you know anything about boxing you'd agree.

[£-4-£]

Calzaghe:
- Eubank (past-prime)
- Robin Reid
- Richie Woodhall
- Byron Mitchell
- Jeff Lacy (prime, undefeated)
- Sakio Bika (prime)
- Manfredo Jr
- Mikkel Kessler (prime, undefeated)
- Bernard Hopkins (past-prime, but he's still schooling boxers today, so Calzaghe gets a lot of credit for this win)
- Roy Jones Jr (past-prime)

Froch:
- Robin Reid (past-prime)
- Jean Pascal (prime, undefeated. went on to win lineal title at 175lbs)
- Jermaine Taylor
- Andre Dirrell (prime, undefeated)
- Arthur Abraham (prime?)
- Close decision loss to Kessler, arguably a draw.

Right now I'd say Calzaghe has a better resume, but after Froch beats Johnson AND Andre Ward, and gets a title win at 175lbs against a good opponent then I'd give it to Froch!