Is the Holyfield/Lewis draw atleast top 5 in the worst decisions all-time? - Page 4

studentofthegam

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonnyboy

so you scored their first fight 118-110?

That sounds about right to me. It was a terrible showing for Evander.

Wild Blue Yonda

I might dare say that Casamayor-Cruz fight has been the single worst decision since Lewis-Holyfield I.

JK1700

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wild Blue Yonda

I might dare say that Casamayor-Cruz fight has been the single worst decision since Lewis-Holyfield I.

It's between that one and Campillo-Shumenov II.

Campillo won at least 10 rounds in his 2nd fight with Shumenov.

SCtrojansbaby

Toney vs Rahman 1, Toney vs Griffin 1 and to a lesser extent Toney vs Peter.

Walt Liquor

Anyone wih Stum-DeLa yet?

Segio V Cintron was clearly the worst decision ever to me as it also had the missed KO.

forbes-demetrious hopkins

I'd say holy-lewis is top 5, that was a straight up stickup, but he got the draw as already quoted

GJC

Quote:

Originally Posted by JAB5239

Please, for the love of God, tell me you aren't trying to argue the second fight was a bigger robbery than the first.

Remarkably 7-5 and 5-7 make the two fights dead level too

In answer to the question Briggs Foreman is a little mentioned gem of a shocking verdict.

joe strong

yes it was....bryd\oquendo was pretty bad too

deansluk

i thought lewis won the 1st 9-3 and the second i scored 7-5 as a lewis fan, coulda been a draw , a robbery ill always remember was james toney vs Dave Tiberi , toney got beat as clearly that night as he did in any of his losses bar the rjj fight , reid vs ottke was bad , sturm dlh was pretty bad , also im a brit , but i thought dirrell beat froch by a few rounds and didnt get the nod in nottingham , quartey vs forrest fight a few years back was iffy ,i thought collazo beat hatton , yeh i guess boxings corrupt lol

Wild Blue Yonda Undisputed Champion Join Date: Nov 2010 Age: 64 Posts: 1,102 Rep Power: 6 Points: 1,000,137,574.59 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 1,000,137,574.59 Donate	I might dare say that Casamayor-Cruz fight has been the single worst decision since Lewis-Holyfield I.

SCtrojansbaby Undisputed Champion Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 5,506 Blog Entries: 2 Rep Power: 15 Points: 30,236,481.32 Bank: 0.00 Total Points: 30,236,481.32 Donate	Toney vs Rahman 1, Toney vs Griffin 1 and to a lesser extent Toney vs Peter.

Walt Liquor the opposite of pure Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: East Broward Posts: 32,744 Rep Power: 95 Points: 10,482,500,133,999.88 Bank: 3,519,174,279,467.96 Total Points: 14,001,674,413,467.84 Donate	Anyone wih Stum-DeLa yet? Segio V Cintron was clearly the worst decision ever to me as it also had the missed KO. forbes-demetrious hopkins I'd say holy-lewis is top 5, that was a straight up stickup, but he got the draw as already quoted

joe strong Undisputed Champion Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Edmonton,Canada Age: 38 Posts: 10,250 Blog Entries: 1 Rep Power: 70 Points: 74,781.90 Bank: 190,608,552,240.93 Total Points: 190,608,627,022.83 Donate	yes it was....bryd\oquendo was pretty bad too