Who deserves the shot at Floyd more: Maidana or Khan?

[ShoulderRoll]

In my opinion Amir has accomplished less at 147.

[RichCCFC]

But Khan beat Maidana. Khan would be the bigger and maybe better fight.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Khan beat Maidana....

[WARQUEZ]

Maidana beat a good little fighter. He deserves the shot. Do I want to see it though? Nope. I would rather see smitty Khan.

[samouraï]

That's been a while. Maidana has looked better recently and has the much better recent resume. Still, Floyd should have an "easy" time with either one, but Maidana is wild and tough so he may make it entertaining.

[-PBP-]

Khan beat Maidana. Khan is the luckiest mother ****er on earth right now with Devon and Broner losing in back to back weeks.

[ElMeroChingon]

In my opinion Amir has accomplished less at 147.

Maidana, and no more peanut "eliminator" fights, he has earned the big payday against Mayweather wether you think he beats him or not, the work he put out today was out of this world.

[BUNGALOWS]

Neither. They both aren't good enough for a PPV with Floyd.

Thurman/Maidana. Winner gets Floyd.

[BUNGALOWS]

Maidana, and no more peanut "eliminator" fights, he has earned the big payday against Mayweather wether you think he beats him or not, the work he put out today was out of this world.

He beat up a guy 50% of the posters were calling an overrated hype job.

[dc3383]

Beating Maidana was Khans was one of his last legit wins and he barely escaped with that win. Khan has done nothing to deserve the fight.