Who has a better chance to beat the ATG in the divsions they fought: Pac or Floyd?

[Benny Leonard]

This goes away from picking and choosing weight and titles. Gets away from just because you are in an era of more divisions, more titles to pick from...that somehow makes you better than others that weren't so fortunate with more divisions, more titles, and actually able to get a fight unlike many fighters back in day. Sorry darky...you’re just too good to fight for the title. In 10 years, we can have even more division given how everybody treats the divisions now. Catchweights? Let's just make them divisions. 140, 144, 147 for example. Let's add more titles: WBC, IBF, WBA, IBO, GFU, STFU, etc.

History is shady.

Like Iceman John Scully said in his ESPN post fight analysis summary: Just think of how many more divisions and titles SRR could have had if he had what they had today in his day.

Or like some have argued...Armstrong.


Anyway...Floyd or Pac.

Who comes out in a head to head against ATG in each of their divisions they fought.

I'm not going to do a poll because I'm too damn tired to think of an accurate poll....although maybe I'll just do it from 130-147 since both have fought in those divisions and the rest of the divisions Pac has fought...throw them in the post-reply.

So, ok, poll will stand at 130-147:

And the both will have to fight since this is fantasy and no catch-weights or past prime fighters. Prime vs. Prime and in each weight division...130-147
Pac has only gotten better anyway.

[jrosales13]

I am going with Floyd at 130. I think Floyd is clearly in the top 3 greatest fighter of all time. Arguebly the G.O.A.T. And, I think Floyd at 130 could possibly beat a lot of great SFW likes Arguello. But, I also think Pac could beat Arguello.

I think both lose at LW against Duran and Whitaker. I am not even going to mention Benny Leonard or Armstron.

I think Chavez beats both fighters at 140. I think Pryor-Pac is a 50-50 fight. I think Floyd beats Pac. And, I don't see them being able to beat any of the ATG at 147. Actually they can beat Carmen Basillo. But, I don't know who else. I think Mosley can beat them now at 147 and he is not ATG WW.