What was the closer fight: Hopkins – Calzaghe or PBF vs. Oscar

[Flawless]

What was the closer fight: Hopkins – Calzaghe or PBF vs. Oscar?

Which fight was closer and you could have a reason to argue the result of that fight. Calzaghe got knocked down. Mayweather also won by a SD, but Oscar did give him rouble with his speed.


To be honest I was thinking about this and couldn't pick an answer

Your thoughts???


PS: This thread is about to glorify Mayweather or discredit Calzaghe. It’s a honest dead set question.

[TheManchine]

hopkins-calzaghe,

i watched the fight again, i didnt score it but i still feel hopkins won,

i really dont like that slapping bull****, either way it was a very close fight that really came down to quantity of punches or quality,

alot of rounds were tought to score,

as for the oscar-floyd fight, i had that 8 rounds to 4 in favour of Floyd,

i thought he won quite clearly but there wasnt much action in the fight

[Flawless]

hungryherbert, S.G.


Reason boys

[Silencers]

Calzaghe-Hopkins was closer IMO.

And it wasn't really DLH's speed that gave Mayweather problems, it was DLH's jab, he has always had a very, very good jab.

[S.G.]

i thought Mayweather's win was pretty clear and Calzaghe vs Hopkins was a 1 point difference either way or draw

so Mayweather - ODLH

[Dan...]

B-Hop-Joe was the closer fight IMO. I thought Floyd beat Oscar pretty clearly. Oscar's efforts that night pretty much defined ineffective aggression.

[Flawless]

Judge Jerry Roth scored the last round for Mayweather, the only judge to do so. Had he scored the twelfth for De La Hoya, the fight would have been a draw. But yeah I have to agree Hopkins - Calzaghe was the closer fight

[T-97]

I scored both fights to the guy that ended up a winner. Except, I had Calzaghe winning 114-113, and Mayweather winning 116-112. That leaves room for Floyd to lose an extra round and still win, But Calzaghe only won, If Hopkins took 1 other round he would have taken the fight on my scorecard.

So, Hopkins-Calzaghe was closer imo.

[DanielTurcotte3]

Hopkins Calz.....Ive watched it 2 times, and am actually set to tonight....Ive scored it 6 apiece with Hopkins winning by the KD, and I scored it 7-5 for Joe, winning despite the KD, again i will watch this probably another 3-4 times scoring it, although everytime i just watch it, I see Hopkins landing the cleaner shots and controlling the fight.......

Floyd won the fight clearly......I also had it 116-112, i had it split in the first 6, 3 apiece, I had Floyd winning the next 5 rounds hands down, he dominated, outlanding DLH by an avg. of about 15 punches in those rounds, and landed the HARDER CLEANER SHOTS...DLH won round 12 on my cards...And everytime I score this I have had the same exact socrecard each time, not once has it been different yet to date...,....

[warp1432]

Floyd landed the cleaner shots on Oscar to really win the rounds clearly. I think Oscar-PBF is pretty easy to tell who won what round (minus round 8, I scored that for Oscar, but it was close)

Hopkins-Calzaghe was a lot more closer and it could have gone either way imo.