If Josesito Lopez BEATS Canelo Is He Instant ATG, P4P top 10, Fighter of the Year?

[Fix]

Lopez already caused a huge upset over Ortiz by coming up from 140 and beating him by RTD. He's now going up yet another division and fighting the WBC champion at 154. If he somehow beats Canelo, would you consider Lopez fighter of the year? Where would he be in your p4p list? Could he even be an instant ATG by those two achievements alone?

[Redd Foxx]

You're pushing a little to hard on this one.

[Kagami Taiga]

no. nowhere near in fact.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

fighter of the year, perhaps...

ATG? c'mon now

[Atreyu Khalil]

Fighter of the year yes, the others hell no

[Bermuda]

definitely fighter of the year imo...i wouldn't necessarily rank him top ten p4p though because a win against canelo would probably prove how much of a hype job canelo is more than anything.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Fighter of the year possibly.

Ortiz has beat some Ok competition and Canelo has absolutely faced nothing but ridiculous opposition. So P4P is out the window and to mention ATG is absurd.

[New England]

you dogs even seen highlander?


when you beat an immortal you cut off his head and you gain his power.

[Fix]

You're pushing a little to hard on this one.

It'd be a great achievement IMO

[ElBossHogg™]

fighter of the year easily. but ATG