Who ranks higher P4P. Roberto Duran or Joe Gans?

[Barn]

Think I'm gonna give it to Duran here by a shade. Could be different tomorrow though.

[NChristo]

Used to think Gans but now imo it's Duran although it's kinda close I think he's definitely ahead too me.

[Barn]

Used to think Gans but now imo it's Duran although it's kinda close I think he's definitely ahead too me.

I would get a better idea if I got off my lazy arse and done my Duran thread.

In all seriousness though, doing MacBeth at school so gotta do a ****load for that. I should have my Duran thread done during the weekend in case anyone was wondering if I had abandoned it.

[Obama]

Gans is in my top 5. Duran may not even be in my top 20.

[Barn]

Gans is in my top 5. Duran may not even be in my top 20.

Do you feel a win on Gans resume is better than Duran's over Sugar Ray?

I know this hasn't got a great deal to do with the ranking.

[BennyST]

This is one of those weird which I could change on a daily basis. I normally put Duran a little higher P4P based on his higher weight wins, but have Gans ahead at 135. He was amazing and has great wins at 135 and 147, but I just can't take away from the Duran wins at 147 up to 160 along with his wins from 118 to 140.