How many of these ten ATG'S will you favor over Floyd Mayweather jr H2H?

[Skittlez]

Roberto Duran at LW
Chavez Senior at LW
Sugar Ray Leonard at WW
Tommy Hearns at WW
Sugar Ray Robinson at WW
Felix Trinidad at WW
Aaron Pyror at LW
ALexis Arguello at LW
Pernell Whitaker at LW
wilfred benitez at WW

[ElBossHogg™]

Ill go with Aaron Pyror cause he is a cheat but if not him roberto duran and if he cant get it done then of course JCC SNR will handle him easily.

[GOD-FR33]

Here you go...........

First, let me sum up Floyd Mayweather. He is nothing more than a hall of famer who could've been an all-time great. What makes an all-time great is the risk factor and respect for your craft. You have to dare to be great and give the fans what they want to see. We like to see the best fight the best. Mayweather is not as "great" as people think he is. Here is my list based off your list.

Sugar Ray Leonard-Too fast of hand and foot, too smart, too much stamina, and too BIG.

Thomas Hearns-Too BIG. Too strong. Too fast. Great jab.

Roberto Duran-Too tough. Threw too many punches for Floyd. Great body puncher and power in both hands.

Possibly Chavez Sr.-Smart pressure fighter. Vicious body puncher. Workrate could possibly win it for him because Floyd doesn't have the best legs. He's a lateral mover.

Felix Tito Trinidad- Great timing, relentless pressure, belief through 12 in his punching power, very quick hands, good jab when he throws it. Versitle puncher with both hands, and very high workrate.

I also believe that Pernell Sweetpea Whitaker would have beaten him soundly. People often compare their defenses but Sweetpea had billion dollar legs and was hard to hit with even a jab. He also defended against better opposition. Floyd is a lateral defender who relies solely on reflexes. He gives you his body and is susceptible to a good jab. His main weakness is his poor workrate. 40-45 punches a round won't help him against these greats. If you can outwork him, you can win on the cards if nothing else. All of these fighters on the list above have high workrates and Floyd would get hit and get hit often. We really don't know how much punishment he can take because he doesn't fight the best enough. He has proven to be durable though.

[FightScorer]

There are only two guys I will say are definite favors at those weight classes.

Tommy Hearns at WW. Common sense. 6'2, a great big man vs a 5'8 former 130 pounder. Hearn's style also is horrible for Floyd.
Sugar Ray Leonard at WW. I think is just overall better.

WW is not really Floyd's prime class. As for Pernell, Duran etc. Of course they can beat Floyd, but it's much much closer than Hearns or Leonard at WW.

[Fasttimes]

Tommy Hearns at WW
Sugar Ray Leonard at WW
Wifred Benitez at WW
Roberto Duran at LW
Whitaker LW
Robinson WW

[SpeedKillz]

Ill go with Aaron Pyror cause he is a cheat but if not him roberto duran and if he cant get it done then of course JCC SNR will handle him easily.

no. i get the JCC SNR myth, i really do, but no...

[The Big Dunn]

Roberto Duran at LW
Chavez Senior at LW
Sugar Ray Leonard at WW
Tommy Hearns at WW
Sugar Ray Robinson at WW
Felix Trinidad at WW
Aaron Pyror at LW
ALexis Arguello at LW
Pernell Whitaker at LW
wilfred benitez at WW

i voted SRL and SRR at ww, with the caveat being I never saw SRR fight live.

[1sballotHOF]

Pretty much a whose who of guys that would beat Floyd. Although, I'd slightly favor Floyd against Tito at WW.

[FightScorer]

Pretty much a whose who of guys that would beat Floyd. Although, I'd slightly favor Floyd against Tito at WW.

I find that hard to agree with. Hearns will most likely beat Floyd. Either via Ko or he will win every single round having Floyd curl into a defensive fetal shell.
Leonard will beat Floyd.

As for 'the rest' it's honestly at worst 40-60. Are you sure Pryor is better than Floyd in a h2h sense? Chavez SR? Sr got the better 'ATG Standings' that' sfor sure. H2H? Hard to say.

[1sballotHOF]

I find that hard to agree with. Hearns will most likely beat Floyd. Either via Ko or he will win every single round having Floyd curl into a defensive fetal shell.
Leonard will beat Floyd.

As for 'the rest' it's honestly at worst 40-60. Are you sure Pryor is better than Floyd in a h2h sense? Chavez SR? Sr got the better 'ATG Standings' that' sfor sure. H2H? Hard to say.

I don't think they win by land slides, but I believe they'd all beat Floyd, besides Tito.