Could a Prime Antonio Margarito (05-09) beat a past prime Mayweather at 37 years old?

[CTC JOHNNY]

Plaster man

[Japanese Boxing]

Wargarito would probably break Floyd's hands if they ever hit his chin.

[UTEP]

We will never know... Just like we won't know how he would of done
Against prime PAC, Williams, Margarito, prime ODH, Cotto, Mosley ect. Thou they were all in the same era & any of those could have been made, but we all know what Floyd did instead. Sadly he gets rated so high on this site.

True. According to Floyd fans he would have beat them all though, the Catchweight King is undefeated in fantasy fights

[Bushidō]

If you are talking the 05-09 Margarito then you are talking about him with plaster and he would have a great shot vs Floyd with that plaster

[SkillspayBills]

Wayyyy to slow to beat Floyd. As long as Floyd stays off the ropes Marg gets potshotted to a 10-2 victory. Any version of Marg vs Any version of Floyd.

[Reloaded]

Wayyyy to slow to beat Floyd. As long as Floyd stays off the ropes Marg gets potshotted to a 10-2 victory. Any version of Marg vs Any version of Floyd.

Yes , Floyd is a mongoose Margo a sloth , look at the Santos fight and Floyd cant out box Margo are these guys kidding , by now people should realize slow fighters have absolutely no chance against Floyd .

[Jcsuper]

Yes , Floyd is a mongoose Margo a sloth , look at the Santos fight and Floyd cant out box Margo are these guys kidding , by now people should realize slow fighters have absolutely no chance against Floyd .

People are stupid. The world is stupid. Guys on this site see a big guy with power and they start to get wet like little girls at a one direction show. People always beg to see a big slow a%% fighter against floyd and when they get it they wonder how come the said guy don't land a single punch on FLoyd.

I honestly think that Margarito's landing ratio would be less than 5% if he had fight against Floyd.

[Frank Ducketts]

True. According to Floyd fans he would have beat them all though, the Catchweight King is undefeated in fantasy fights

If you keep speaking while out on disability, I'm going to fine and suspend you. Stop talking about boxing for about 2 months or else! It's bad enough you picked Matthysse to kill Danny Garcia and now you just saying anything because you're pissed!?

[DARKSEID]

I'm just going to say it bluntly, there's a lot of ****ing morons in this place.

Boxing is the sport of toughness and mental strength, it's the sport where your will alone can compensate for all of your weaknesses if it's strong enough.

You don't ****ing sleep on a Prime Antonio Margarito. They don't come much tougher than him. NOBODY beats a Prime Antonio Margarito easily. NOBODY walks through a Prime Antonio Margarito.

Nobody likes to take about this but the truth is Antonio Margarito went into the shane mosley training camp 40 pounds overweight. He had to lose 40 pounds in less then a month and a half. Maybe they tried the plaster because they were in a desperate situation.

Maybe they didn't get away with it because the commission is so good at catching cheaters, proof being they didn't get away with it, and nobody else has for decades in the prizefighting league.

Do you know why guys were getting destroyed by him? Because Margarito had power, and even if he didn't hit the hardest, he certainly tried the most times. When you get hit as much and as hard as margarito's opponents were getting hit, it's not hard to see why they would start getting busted up.

He has power, just not knockout power, and he throws a higher volume of power punches than anyone I can think of.

Edit: Paul Williams is the only one I can think of that might be close.

[DARKSEID]

Floyd might not be pretty boy anymore but his pretty boy fans are still around lol