Toney vs Hopkins.. better resume?

[RichCCFC]

Toney hands down for me.

[ninerdude90]

I'd say Hopkins, and I don't think it's all that close really.

[Mato o Muero]

I'd say Hopkins, and I don't think it's all that close really.

This. Skill level can be debated but you can't compare their resumes.

[pturtle]

Hopkins has the bigger names and toney has the tougher fights.

Anyone who doesn’t think its debatable doesn’t know how good the fighters toney beat were.

Toney wins are much better then Hopkins in my opinion. whose a tougher fight, Mike McCallum or blown up trinidad? blown up oscar or Michael Nunn? Tarver or Jirov? Toney resume to me edges Hopkins

[LeG00N]

Toney is definitely more skilled

[Deathknight88]

Lmao.

Jesus Christ.

brb.

[Mr. Fantastic]

It's funny how when it comes to black boxers, people seem to be scared to call them cheaters and stuff. Since most people on here are cheater avengers, they should automatically void Toney since he got busted twice and easily pick Hopkins.

[The Gambler1981]

I would say B-Hop based on overall longevity, also Toney has some excellent wins but several bad loses that B-Hop doesn't really have and I don't think that can be overlooked.

[CHOWWOKKA]

It's funny how when it comes to black boxers, people seem to be scared to call them cheaters and stuff. Since most people on here are cheater avengers, they should automatically void Toney since he got busted twice and easily pick Hopkins.

[Light_Speed]

Hopkins has the bigger names and toney has the tougher fights.

Anyone who doesn’t think its debatable doesn’t know how good the fighters toney beat were.

Toney wins are much better then Hopkins in my opinion. whose a tougher fight, Mike McCallum or blown up trinidad? blown up oscar or Michael Nunn? Tarver or Jirov? Toney resume to me edges Hopkins

You need to take the losses and the consistency (or lack thereof) into account.