Originally posted by New England
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Who was the hardest punching Middleweight Ever?
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by McGoorty View PostYeah but there is plenty of footage of the 50's,........ miles and miles of film with live commentary. I never even hear you talk about anybody from the 50's,...... I just get frustrated by short posts with the same usual suspects. It's fine to have your favourites, but is there anything wrong with looking around for other fighters TO ADD TO THE ONES YOU LIKE ALREADY. I have favourites too, but I want to hear about fighters that I know little about....... I'm always trying to expand. Have you never picked up a book about old fights and just read ?????...... it's fun and educational.Last edited by SCtrojansbaby; 09-14-2011, 12:34 PM.
Comment
-
Not on the list or even been mentioned, what about Marvin Hagler? Hagler had a hell of a punch on him!
I wouldn't say him personally just a bit shocked nobody mentioned him as IMO his power is right up there & the the opposition he was knocking out was as good if not better than most/all those guys.
For me it's between the G-man & Hearns. I think I am probably going to go with the G-man.
Comment
-
Originally posted by SCtrojansbaby View PostCan you show me at least 5 full fights of Carmen Basillo or Bob Fitzsimmons or Stanley Ketchel or anyone else you want me to talk about and at least 1 other fight that the opponents in those 5 fights were in. You do that I promise I will take an interest in them
Comment
-
Jackson had some excellent MW power and probably top 10 for sure, but not #1 or top 5 even, but top 10 yes, most of his devasting power were at JMW when he moved, from what I've seen on film and read from experts, he lost a fair amount of that power when he moved up, but still awesome, I would rate him on par with Hearns at MW.
Comment
-
I would rate Robinson at MW just above Hearns & J. Jackson at MW, but at JMW I Robinson would probably pick up a bit more power as he moved closer to his best weight at WW but at JMW I would give Jackson the nod over RObinson. it does not seem like it and many don't believe it, but they do lose or gain depending on the weight they move up or down in, a great like Robinson would for example on a scale of 10 in power I would rate a 9 at WW and and an 8 at JMW and a very high 7 at MW. Jackson I give a 10 at JMW and at MW a solid 7, I just think he lost a good deal of power moving up.
Comment
-
You take an interest in all - time greats because of what is written about them by the people that saw them fight and that took the time to detail their fights and what they saw in comparison to other fighters they also got to see, some over many years, and then their records and competetion, that's why most intelligent Boxing fans and experts take an interest, LES DARCY won only the MW Title of his own country, no way you can judge him as you have no clue on the competition he fought there, 2 fights with Jeff Smith does not tell you a thing, and even against weak Australian competition his KO was not phenomenal, which it should have been there, if he had the power you speak of.
Comment
Comment