Andre Ward is the greatest Super Middleweight ever!

[crold1]

No other super middleweight has ever had two wins the caliber of Ward spanking Kessler and Froch.

Calzaghe sparked Kess and Lacy pretty good arguably past his physical peak though Froch is clearly a better win than Lacy. Toney and being the only man to stop Malinga is pretty darn good for Roy. Eubank and Benn had big wins; Collins beat them both. There's a lot of depth for a young-ish class.

Ward's on a roll. Bute would be huge for him. he's fighting in a stellar era for the class.

[GoogleMe]

Calzaghe has a way better resume.

[The Surgeon]

Calzaghe should be EMBARRASSED that threads like these are popping up ALREADY given the length of his "reign".....

I doubt he'd have even entered this tournament if it happened on his watch, if he did he'd have pulled out mid way im sure of it.

[Obama]

Calzaghe should be EMBARRASSED that threads like these are popping up ALREADY given the length of his "reign".....

I doubt he'd have even entered this tournament if it happened on his watch, if he did he'd have pulled out mid way im sure of it.

And this is pretty much the bottom line right here. Better fighter or not, Calzaghe simply never played the part.

[Obama]

lol dream on 46-0only man in history to win wba,wbo,wbc.ibf,ibo

Calzaghe never won an IBO title. And he's not the only one to hold the 4 main ones either. Bernard Hopkins did, and he held them all at the same time, unlike Calzaghe.

[Canelo Phresh]

i think bute is tougher than froch

[jermainerambo]

Calzaghe never won an IBO title. And he's not the only one to hold the 4 main ones either. Bernard Hopkins did, and he held them all at the same time, unlike Calzaghe.

jeff lacy was the ibf and ibo champion

joe calzaghe had all the belts and beat Bernard Hopkins

[crold1]

jeff lacy was the ibf and ibo champion

joe calzaghe had all the belts and beat Bernard Hopkins

No, he vacated the IBF belt before Kessler. That's how it ultimately ended up with Bute. he won all the belts. he didn't hold them all at the same time.

[wmute]

Not yet, but he is well on his way to get there.

[Obama]

jeff lacy was the ibf and ibo champion

joe calzaghe had all the belts and beat Bernard Hopkins

No, he vacated the IBF belt before Kessler. That's how it ultimately ended up with Bute. he won all the belts. he didn't hold them all at the same time.

He didn't hold the IBO title at all. It was vacated after Lacy-Sandman.