Let's keep it reality, payton manning is a choker

[-Swizzy-]

4000+ Yard seasons
Manning 11(out of 12 seasons)
Marino 6
Elway 1
Young 2
Brady 3 (out of 9 full seasons)
Montana 0

65+ completion percentage seasons
Manning 9
Marino 0
Elway 0
Young 6
Brady 3
Montana 2


nobody touches Manning. Too bad football is a team game yet individual players are still measured by how many championships they won even if they've played on **** teams their whole careers.

[Addition]

GOAT regular season player.

[-Swizzy-]

GOAT regular season player.

He's been in the league for 12 seasons. Can't judge him off 1 or 2 playoffs where he hasn't played well in a couple of games. Are we forgetting the comeback win in the 4th quarter against the Patriots?

Oh and btw, he has a ring. The Colts defense that year was overrated. The Colts as a whole have never had a good roster since Manning has been there. He takes an average roster and makes it look great.

[jmasta]

The GOAT

[bojangles1987]

4000+ Yard seasons
Manning 11(out of 12 seasons)
Marino 6
Elway 1
Young 2
Brady 3 (out of 9 full seasons)
Montana 0

65+ completion percentage seasons
Manning 9
Marino 0
Elway 0
Young 6
Brady 3
Montana 2


nobody touches Manning. Too bad football is a team game yet individual players are still measured by how many championships they won even if they've played on **** teams their whole careers.

Maybe not winning championships is held against him because he doesn't play half as good in the playoffs as he does in the regular season?

And lol at the Colts having sh** teams around Manning.

[BTL]

Payton is not seeing what Brady is doing.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Bump....


He looked horrible in the Super Bowl.. Great in regular season

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Bump....


He looked horrible in the Super Bowl.. Great in regular season

gimme Peyton in the regular season and his brother for playoffs

[Sugar Adam Ali]

gimme Peyton in the regular season and his brother for playoffs

Exactly,, that would be the goat

[$tate of Mind]

How the hell can he be the GOAT when he consistently comes up short in the playoffs? His regular season statistics don't mean jack when he can't back it up in the post season. Aaron Rodgers is the best QB in football.