At Their Peak, Who is the most Dominant Fighter Of All Time?

[NChristo]

Michael Spinks is up there.

[Drunken Cat]

Does dominating numerous top 10 contenders in your division with 2 dominating wins over future hall of famers mean that you are on of the most dominant fighters in your era?

Does being the undisputed champion at light heavyweight mean that you were dominant?

Does winning world titles at Middleweight, Super Middleweight, Light Heavyweight and Heavyweight a sign of dominance?

Or how about being the first middleweight champion to win a heavyweight title in over 106 years?

I think so.

I'm not going to defend his resume because it lags against other all time greats. But to deny this man's dominance in his prime is just hating.

Does beating one of the worst heavyweight "champions" of all time diminish the accomplishment?

Funny thing is that Toney beat the same "champ." I don't care if Jones administered his steroids more effectively in order to beat the testing.

[Drunken Cat]

I suppose that Floyd may deserve some mention, based on the simple test: who around his weight division does anyone see him losing to?

[SCtrojansbaby]

Again, Roy Jones resume is mediocre. B-/C+ at best. But as I've stated in my other post, his level of dominance during his era cannot be questioned. Especially when seeing how he toyed with the #3 pound for pound fighter in the world at the time.

Roy has the best or second best resume of the last 40-50 years. But squares like you aren't knowledgeable enough to appreciate DOMINANT wins over guys like Thulani Malinga or Jorge Castro.

[-PBP-]

Does beating one of the worst heavyweight "champions" of all time diminish the accomplishment?

Funny thing is that Toney beat the same "champ." I don't care if Jones administered his steroids more effectively in order to beat the testing.

James Toney is a 2X fighter of the year award winner, an ATG and a shoe in for the International Boxing Hall of Fame.

Why would a fighter of Toney's caliber defeating a common opponent diminish that achievement?

[Mr. Fantastic]

Roy has the best or second best resume of the last 40-50 years. But squares like you aren't knowledgeable enough to appreciate DOMINANT wins over guys like Thulani Malinga or Jorge Castro.

Wow!!!!!!!!!!!

[A-Wolf]

RJJ

At his peak RJJ dominates ANYBODY P4P from any era. His speed, power, athletiscim and the way he was so unorthodox.

Oh hell no. He doesn't dominate the ATGs. Dominates? Absolutely not.

[-PBP-]

Roy has the best or second best resume of the last 40-50 years. But squares like you aren't knowledgeable enough to appreciate DOMINANT wins over guys like Thulani Malinga or Jorge Castro.

Not taking the bait. I'm untrollable.

[sdcluser]

Sugar Ray? Tyson? Roy?

RJJ - Moves like a featherweight and punches like a heavyweight

[revs1227]

srr
armstrong
2 greatest ever
also greb

right now the klitschkos are pretty damn dominate