if YOU had a vote..would gatti,tarver get into the hall of fame??

[larry x]

just curious..me personally...**** it let them in

[El Dominicano]

just curious..me personally...**** it let them in

I'd say yes to Gatti, not sure about Tarver.

[J.B.moneY.]

i would vote yes for both, but reluctant vote for tarver....but he barely gets in.....gatti is a lock

[Ryn0]

Gatti yea but he proberbly doesn't deserve it I mean I love watching the guy but he's not really a legendary fighter, Tarver wouldn't get my vote.

[larry x]

gatti shed enough blood to get in..and id let tarver in for beating roy alone...thats an amazing feat

[Ivansmamma]

no none of them

[talip bin osman]

just curious..me personally...**** it let them in

were u banned my man? what happened?

[dondi330]

I dont think either deserve it.
Tarver is nothing special and Gatti had wars with Ward(thats what made him big). But that isn't saying much, No question Gatti was a warrior and had a lot of heart. But you need more than heart for the HOF. I mean he took a beating very well and kept fighting, that isn't HOF material.

[Dan...]

Yes to Gatti. Tarver is a real borderline case. I guess it comes down to how much of a feat you think beating Roy was at that stage. Personally I think any decent LHW would have beaten the Roy he fought, so I would probably go no.

[larry x]

were u banned my man? what happened?

for speaking my mind in a non offensive manner