if oscar is an atg..then isnt judah aswell??

[infamous larryx]

both fought the best...and lost

[-Rab]

I hate Oscar but he's fought better competition than Floyd.

[dj Ramos]

judah got bodied, oscar didnt most of his losses are contrverstial

[infamous larryx]

I hate Oscar but he's fought better competition than Floyd.

this isnt about floyd..where did i mention floyd???

[etlux]

both fought the best...and lost

Oscar beat Pernel Whitaker
beat Julio Cesar Chavez


that's 2 ATG's


Beat Vargas
Beat Mosley
Beat Trinidad

That's HOF'ers

Beat Ike Quartey, Molina, Camacho, Carr, and many other very good fighters.

Who has Judah beat? Spinks? Doesn't even compare

[johncods]

Come on man who did judah beat?? And for the record I don't think Oscar is one of the best fighters ever(ATG) but judah is **** compared to Oscar.

[Heeb]

ATG List>Oscar>Zab

[flipbjefrox]

judah doesnt have one good win and plus you would hardly consider clottey an baldomir an atg

[Team Money May]

TS has a point: Judah is top 5 ATG.

[Sweet Jesus]

Both have won a bunch of titles, 5 for Zab and 10 for Oscar. But I don't think either of them were truly great. They were definitely in the next tier though in their primes.