Naseem Hamed or Antonio Tarver who place's higher on a all time great list?

[Joey Giardello]

Naseem Hamed or Antonio Tarver who place's higher on a all time great list?

[Rip Chudd]

Is this a serious question!?

[Barn]

Gotta be Hamed.

[studentofthegam]

Hamd by a hair. I guess because he only had one loss and hung them up on time.

[baya]

tarver. he's the one who first beat the living legend RJJ.

hamed's never done anything close to that.

[Scott9945]

Hamed, and IMO it isn't even close.

[fitefanSHO]

Tarver ftw +1, he played Mason "The Line" Dixon in Rocky Balboa!

[bklynboy]

Naseem Hamed or Antonio Tarver who place's higher on a all time great list?

Neither belong on a ATG list. Naseem didn't continue after his loss to Barrera. I can't see him even beginning to be considered to be in the TOP 20.

(If you're not in the TOP 20 of your division how can you even be considered to be in a TOP 100 list?)

As for Tarver he was a good Light-Heavy - but beating a 35 year old Roy Jones doesn't make him an ATG.

[fitefanSHO]

OK, but who currently WEIGHS more?

[bklynboy]

OK, but who currently WEIGHS more?

OK, now that's sad, it reminds me of Ben Stiller getting fat at the end of Dodgeball.