Quality vs. Quantity: Who has the better resume?

[emurgencee]

Adrien Broner or Canelo Alvarez?

[Larry the boss]

Canelo easily

[kiaba360]

I would choose quantity in this instance, because Broner doesn't have much quality on his resume. It's not like he cleaned out the 130lb division, his only notable fights are Litzau/Ponce/Escobedo.

[emurgencee]

canelo's notable fights are matthew hatton, ryan rhodes, shane mosley, kermit cintron and danny garcia. and these were ALL title fights lol. when was matthew hatton or ryan rhodes EVER eligible for a title shot lol. At least Broner fought Deleon BEFORE he became world champ.

[kiaba360]

canelo's notable fights are matthew hatton, ryan rhodes, shane mosley, kermit cintron and danny garcia. and these were ALL title fights lol. when was matthew hatton or ryan rhodes EVER eligible for a title shot lol. At least Broner fought Deleon BEFORE he became world champ.

When did he fight Danny Garcia? I think you mean Josesito Lopez lol, but I can see how you would make that mistake, since both are 140lbers.

I know Canelo's resume is weak as fuck, but he's still fought more recognizable names. Broner has half the amount of fights, so it's not even fair to compare them yet. At least Broner is fighting guys from his weight-class.

We'll come back to this after he finishes with 135.

[SPREAD]

Alvarez doesn't have a resume, he has a criminal record where he assaulted guys who shouldn't be in a boxing ring, OAP's called Mosley, and or smaller men/midgets see Lopez, Hatton and more literally Archie Solis.

Broner.

[Hougigo]

Both are weak in quality, Canelo wins by quantity

[HeroBando]

Alvarez doesn't have a resume, he has a criminal record where he assaulted guys who shouldn't be in a boxing ring, OAP's called Mosley, and or smaller men/midgets see Lopez, Hatton and more literally Archie Solis.

Broner.

[Fighting_Pride]

hands down it's alvarez, and i'm not even mexican. broner hasn't defeated anyone worth mentioning.

[DoktorSleepless]

I give Broner more credit for Litzau than most people do. He was coming off a great win over Caballero. I only vaguely remember watching the Ponce fight and I didn't think it was the robbery people made it out to be.

Still not sure about the better resume though. I'm leaning towards Broner.