Originally Posted by Sugarj
To be honest though, I think 1948 Walcott does a much more decisive job on 1936 Louis than Schmelling did.
The Louis that met Schmelling first time would have been demolished by quite a few heavyweights. Louis was on poor form that night......even allowing for his defensive lapses and lazy left, he wasn't nearly as on form or on fire as he was for say the Baer fight.
I will grant you that the Louis fight was Schmelling's best fight.
And for the sake of goodwill I do rate the second Schmelling fight as being one of Louis's best wins. Certainly top five, possibly top three.
All in all...a damn fine debate!