Trading Block Tycoon
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Bright Lights Bigger City, New York
Quoted: 16 Post(s)
Rep Power: 59
Total Points: 170,367,463,032,751.28
Holmes has some solid wins but his best win is Norton who was still good but not prime...I thought he beat Spinks the 2nd time and Cooney is a good win...
Floyd hasn't beat any PRIME great fighters but Judah, Hatton, Corrales, Castillo, Ortiz are solid wins and although Oscar was old, Cotto wasn't Cotto anymore, and Marquez was at 147 they are still respectable wins...not to mention the Marquez win looks a whole lot better now...
Regardless Floyd's legacy will always be stained for not fighting Pacquiao...
EDIT: Forgot about Holmes' wins over Shavers, that 2nd fight was brutal, I mean Holmes was beating the living **** outta Shavers and he wouldn't go down towards the end...I still give the nod to Floyd but its close