Originally Posted by jabsRstiff
Sub-elite slicksters aren't as popular as sub-elite brawlers/punchers, that's a fact that you cannot deny.
Maybe I can't deny it... but popularity should not be a factor in determining who makes it into the HOF.
Heck, Butter Bean was more popular than a lot of guys who are actually in the IBHOF. Should that fat turd get a plaque in Canastota?