People the thread asks who's greater, Not who would win the fight, Calzaghe' best wins are Lacy(superbum), RJJ(10 years removed from when he would have put Calzaghe in hospital), Hopkins(a fight i thought he lost).
Winky beat Vargas(robbery)
beat Jermain (robbed)
Beat Trinidad with ease
Out boxed Ike Quartey
Deserved atleast a draw against Hopkins
Oh and had Winky rematched Vargas when Mosley did then its a total shut out.
You think Calzaghe beat a prime Jones Jnr and Hopkins you mad!, aswell as a prime Eubank.
This guy is still probaly going round retirement homes looking for fights to boost his record.