Morales, Barrera, Marquez: Rank them

[dans]

The three big Mexican small fighters: rank them in terms of their all time standing. I'll start:

1. Morales
2. Barrera
3. JM Marquez

Even though Barrera won the Morales trilogy, I still see Morales as the more accomplished of the two.

[Ian_ST24i]

1-Barrera
2-Morales
3-Marquez

That's at present. By the time JMM finishes his career he could make no.1 IMO.

[Dynamite Kid]

The three big Mexican small fighters: rank them in terms of their all time standing. I'll start:

1. Morales
2. Barrera
3. JM Marquez

Even though Barrera won the Morales trilogy, I still see Morales as the more accomplished of the two.

Barrera
Morales
JMM

[Fox McCloud]

Marquez will probably end up being #1.

As the threadstarter said, I have Morales above Barrera too.

Barrera clearly won 2 out of their 3 trilogy fights IMO, but none of the three fights were such utter domination that it can make up for the gaps in Barrera's career that Morales was able to fill in in his own career.

Barrera = 0-2 vs. Jones.
Morales = 1-0 with a resounding 4th round KO.

Barrera = 0-2 vs. Pacquiao, with neither fight being even remotely close.
Morales = 1-2 vs. Pacquiao, with 2 of the 3 being pretty close, including a win.

It's awfully close though.

[gancho_al_igado]

This is a real tough one for me, i would have to say:
Barrera
Marquez
Morales ....but Marquez and barrera could arguably be #1 also

[Dynamite Kid]

Morales only claim to be above MAB is that he beat Pac when he still had something left he was shot to **** in the second two fights they had and Morales also beat Junior Jones but lets face it,it was a bad style match up for Barrera thats why Jones beat MAB, Mckinney Ko'ed Jones and Barrera hammered McKinney ,also Jones was on the slide when Morales beat him

as for his win over Pac ,Barrera beat Morales twice legitimately

[-MAKAVELLI-]

El Terrible
Marquez
Barrera

[713832281]

marquez
morales
barrera

[i box apples]

morales and barrera on top.

marquez on the bottom.

only a moron would put marquez above those 2 all time greats.

marquez has good skills but look at his resume. controversial losses don't count.

[i box apples]

marquez
morales
barrera

an alt? a moron?

probably both.