http://www.nndb.com/people/354/000023285/sugar-ray-robinson-1.jpg

Name: Sugar Ray Robinson
Career Record: 173-19-6 (KOs 108) Total 200
Stance: Orthodox
Height: 5' 11
Reach: 72"

http://espn-att.starwave.com/media/box/2006/0330/photo/w_mayweather_195.jpg

Name: Floyd Mayweather Jr
Career Record: 37-0-0 (KOs 24) Total 37
Stance: Orthodox
Height: 5' 8
Reach: 72''

You've got the best pound 4 pound fighter of all time vs. the best pound 4 pound fighter of today, who wins? I say SRR takes the win by SD. your thoughts?

Bad bad thread.

SRR by KO, this matchup is a joke

Robinson by death!

Floyds defense and bicycle technique shows that this isn't a joke.. I'd pick Robinson by UD in a 12 round fight, if there was more rounds involved I'd pick Robinson by a possible KO, it wouldn't be a blow out though, lesser opponents went the distance with SRR.

True. But PBF hasnt been tested by somone half as good as Robisnson. Robinson was KOing middleweights with one punch well after his prime. I think he would hurt PBF, outwork him, and out fight him.

True. But PBF hasnt been tested by somone half as good as Robisnson. Robinson was KOing middleweights with one punch well after his prime. I think he would hurt PBF, outwork him, and out fight him.

Sugar ray, the real sugar, was a devastating puncher at welterweight. i've seen films of him ****ing guys up with one punch. as good as pbf is, he's no match for the real sugar. robinson would **** him up in the later rounds. jl castillo, a great fighter was able to frustrate pbf, SRR was a lot better than castillo. robinson would be a nightmare for pbf

There really would be no contest. Floyd Mayweathers skill and speed would be both matched and over-shadowed by Sugar Ray Robinson. The greatest fighter of all time takes Mayweather to school, gives him a terrible beating and puts him on the canvas for keeps inside of ten rounds.

Sugar Ray Robinson by ko.

There is nothing Mayweather has now that Sugar Ray Robinson didn't have back when he fought. Real tough night for Floyd and he'll be KO'd within 8 rounds.

SRR would woop PBF's ass bigtime.

robinson would win by quite easy decision or ko

floyd would defnitely outbox em
but sugar would knock em out..easily

we all seen how robinson knocked out people who were outboxing him

this is some type of joke, right? Robinson will be the one lookin pretty after beating Floyd.

There really would be no contest. Floyd Mayweathers skill and speed would be both matched and over-shadowed by Sugar Ray Robinson. The greatest fighter of all time takes Mayweather to school, gives him a terrible beating and puts him on the canvas for keeps inside of ten rounds.

Sugar Ray Robinson by ko.
I totally agree with M26 . Floyd will wake up in the hospital the next day and say , "What happened?"
The Doctor replys, ".....You have diabetes , Floyd....diabetes"

As M26 said Sugar in 10 rounds by a massive combo Knockout!

Every morning when Floyd wake up, the first thing he better do is Thank God that Sugar Ray Robinson isn't fighting now.

Who would win and how? Well, let me put it this way, this fight couldn't be held in any state where the death penalty has been outlawed.

True. But PBF hasnt been tested by somone half as good as Robisnson. Robinson was KOing middleweights with one punch well after his prime. I think he would hurt PBF, outwork him, and out fight him.Different time, different era!

Robinson by brutal ko in five rounds or less.

the only thing pbf has over robinson is defense.

robinson has a relevant advantage in size, and a HUGE one in power

speed and skills are on par

i want to be generous to pbf's chin and leave this as a question mark (rating robinson above would only be based on lack of evidence on pbf's chin).

anyway mayweather power is surely not enough to trouble robinson.

in a nutshell... it would be cute and interesting to see floyd make robinson miss a few times in unseen ways... for a VERY short while. until the strain of dealing with a bigger opponents who lands bombs at every punch. would get to pbf who would start tasting the canvas until unable to get up.

(or the haters would say he'd quit before that, again based on lack of evidence in favor of his heart, rather than the existence of any evidence against)

SRR wins hands down, by decision or by KO, Quite capable of outboxing or out blasting Floyd!

SRR wins hands down, by decision or by KO, Quite capable of outboxing or out blasting Floyd!
Lol poor pretty boy....no one thinks he could win, but then again everyone thinking/knowing you would lose to Ray Robinson isn't a insult at all! I'm really looking forward to his Oscar fight!

Different time, different era!

Im not sure what ur point is.

robinson would kill him in the ring.

True. But PBF hasnt been tested by somone half as good as Robisnson. Robinson was KOing middleweights with one punch well after his prime. I think he would hurt PBF, outwork him, and out fight him.

I agree.

Still I think Floyd would lose the dec.

He's a blown up fighter at 147, stop tyring to discredit mayweather u ***s.