View Full Version : the 3 worst decision in the last 10 years!!
acquitted 10-10-2004, 04:27 PM what do u guys think are the worst decisions in the last 10 years
de la hoya vs trinidad...de la hoya outboxed this guy 9 or 10 rounds outta 12..and still lost..its sad that de la hoya didnt throw a punch the last round and the judges gave de la hoya the round
lewis vs holyfield 1..lewis manhandled holyfield like his son..its arugeable that holy didnt win a round
being that i couldnt think of a thrid i have to go with FOREST VS MAYORGA 2..when u stick u head out their like ricardo did..and get hit with a 4 punch combo that does score points right?
judges these days are too into the crowd..when a guy starts throwing crazy punches the crowd gets all exicited even if their not hitting via tarver vs jones 1..nobody ever saw jonse lean on the ropes up until that point so they say he lost..no!
neils7147933 10-10-2004, 06:06 PM what do u guys think are the worst decisions in the last 10 years
de la hoya vs trinidad...de la hoya outboxed this guy 9 or 10 rounds outta 12..and still lost..its sad that de la hoya didnt throw a punch the last round and the judges gave de la hoya the round
lewis vs holyfield 1..lewis manhandled holyfield like his son..its arugeable that holy didnt win a round
being that i couldnt think of a thrid i have to go with FOREST VS MAYORGA 2..when u stick u head out their like ricardo did..and get hit with a 4 punch combo that does score points right?
judges these days are too into the crowd..when a guy starts throwing crazy punches the crowd gets all exicited even if their not hitting via tarver vs jones 1..nobody ever saw jonse lean on the ropes up until that point so they say he lost..no!
Lewis-Holyfield I is the only decision I agree was incorrect.
I'm a fairly new boxing fan; except for big heavyweight fights I didn't watch til just a few years ago.
The worst couple judges decisions recently:
Rico Hoye vs. Montell Griffin
Fres Oquendo vs. Chris Byrd
Matt Vanda vs. Sam Garr
BrooklynBomber 10-10-2004, 08:13 PM Hoye vs Griffin
Pacquio vs Marques
Lewis vs Holyfield
Sir_Jose 10-10-2004, 08:24 PM Pac/Marquez isn't even in the conversation. That was a good close fight
1. Lewis vs Holyfield
2. Chavez vs Whitiker(I think this is 10 years)
3. DLH vs Tito
HomicideHank 10-10-2004, 09:25 PM 1- Courtney Burton vs Emmanuel Agustus
2- Lennox Lewis vs Evander Holyfield I
3- Evander Holyfield vs John Ruiz III
Sir_Jose 10-10-2004, 09:35 PM 1- Courtney Burton vs Emmanuel Agustus
2- Lennox Lewis vs Evander Holyfield I
3- Evander Holyfield vs John Ruiz III
Lewis vs Holyfield has to be #1 just because of the size of the fight. You two legit all time great heavyweights fighting fo the undisputed heavyweight championship of the world in Madison Sqaure Garden with the entire sporting world watching.
Burton vs Augustus was a meaningless FNF main event, not that it wan't a robbery or anything cause it was
HomicideHank 10-10-2004, 09:43 PM Agreed. That Burton-Agustus is still in my top 3 though. So bad it has to be.
Tha Greatest 10-10-2004, 10:21 PM DLH-Trinidad NO QUESTION!!
Sir_Jose 10-10-2004, 10:23 PM DLH-Trinidad NO QUESTION!!
AVATAR THIEF!!
THRILLAinmanila 10-11-2004, 01:42 AM undefinedHoye vs Griffin
Pacquio vs Marques
Lewis vs Holyfield
Pacquiao-Marquez is the worst decision for me.
Pacman should have been declared winner by virtue
of being the more superior hitter.
Pound4Pound1986 10-11-2004, 01:46 AM Castillo vs. Mayweather jr. I
D.L.H. vs. Trinidad
Pacquiao vs. Marquez
if judges knew how to score these guys would of been the winners
also why ten years and we can only pick 3
TheGreat1 10-11-2004, 01:56 AM Holyfield vs. LL 2
Holyfield dominated the 2nd fight, He only lost because the judges felt they should repay LL for the 1st fight.
Wlad vs. Williamson
HomicideHank 10-11-2004, 08:00 AM why ten years and we can only pick 3
Because he said so... :D
Seriously, if we did "Top-20 all-time Robberies" , we'd be *****ing that we needed 50 spots. There's just SOOO many foul decisions in the history of this fine sport, we could go all day.
its true you have to have some parameters, lewis holyfield 1 takes some beating though.
nice avatar Hank, and even nicer nic-name I take it you are a fan of of Mr Armstong. :cool:
Hail to the great one!!!!
Your dead on dude, for all of you taking about Holy/Lewis 1, yeah your all right Lewis got ****ed in that one, but as much as he got ****ed in the first fight Holy got screwed in the second fight, that was a make up call and a fight that very few people ever mention regarding bad decisions, thanks for bringing that up Great One!
LuKahnLi 10-11-2004, 03:41 PM Fenech-Nelson I.
Chavez-Whitaker.
Morales-Barrera I.
NiGe2011 10-11-2004, 06:44 PM Holyfield vs. LL 2
Holyfield dominated the 2nd fight, He only lost because the judges felt they should repay LL for the 1st fight.
Wlad vs. Williamson
I am not sure about this one, while I can definitally see you making a case for Holyfield having won the fight- it was a close bout and there is just as much of a case (if not more of one) for Lennox! The decision was far more legit then the first Lennox Lewis VS Evander Holyfield fight was.
Sir_Jose 10-11-2004, 06:47 PM Holyfield vs. LL 2
Holyfield dominated the 2nd fight, He only lost because the judges felt they should repay LL for the 1st fight.
Wlad vs. Williamson
It was closer than the first but make no mistake Lewis won the 2nd fight CLEAN
Dark Destroyer 10-11-2004, 06:47 PM Sugar Shane Mosley Vs Oscar De La Hoya 2
My mind has gone blank but this fights result annoyed me.
Yarmez 10-11-2004, 09:37 PM Lewis VS Holyfield is definetely the worst decision in the last 10 years, man i watch it over and over, and there is no way holyfield won a gingle round.
Dela Hoya VS Tito - I thoght dela hoya won that fight convincingly, yeah he only rallied at the end of rounds, but he still won the fight i feel.
Dela Hoya VS Mosely 2 - while i agree with the judges on the first fight, man they got it wrong in the second, dela hoya whooped mosely no doubt.
acquitted 10-11-2004, 09:58 PM Castillo vs. Mayweather jr. I
D.L.H. vs. Trinidad
Pacquiao vs. Marquez
if judges knew how to score these guys would of been the winners
also why ten years and we can only pick 3
ur list sucks... other then dlh vs trinidad, pac won the first rounds but its arugable that he didnt win another round..but he won the first 3 so big that IT WAS A DRAW...mayweather would hit costillo 3 times and costillo would hit him once..mayweather won that easily
m00ks 10-11-2004, 10:02 PM ur list sucks... other then dlh vs trinidad, pac won the first rounds but its arugable that he didnt win another round..but he won the first 3 so big that IT WAS A DRAW...mayweather would hit costillo 3 times and costillo would hit him once..mayweather won that easily
Its bad judging because
1)115-110 for BOTH fighters....too big of a discrepancy
2)Scroing mistake
QueenCity 10-11-2004, 10:08 PM mayweather would hit costillo 3 times and costillo would hit him once..mayweather won that easily
I saw that fight diffrently, I saw Castillo manhandle him from the middle of the fight to the end. I was completly shocked when they announced Mayweather got that lopsided a dision. In my eyes Castillo was robbed that night.
ghostbear 10-12-2004, 01:22 AM I'm gonna ignore the 10 year limit and say Hagler Leonard. Those little pitter pat flurries didn't convince me any!
to be honest anyone who thinks the Pacaman Marquez fight was a robbery is just too much of a pacman fan to be taken seriously.
Pac won the first big as we know the second round 10-9 and the tenth only in my book, the rest of the time he got a total boxing lesson. Personally I gave it to Marquez by a round but couldnt argue with a draw however there is NO WAY pacman won that fight and to state it was a robbery is simply laughable.
but hey scoring subjective, Im not haivng a go at pacman fans here and to illustrate when i watched Lewis fight Vitali so hyped and pumped was I that I had lewis up a round at the time of the stoppage, clearly that wasnt the case.
Proof if you wanna be totally subjective you need to watch it in the cold light of day and probably atleast twice! :cool:
Dark Destroyer 10-12-2004, 06:52 AM Lewis VS Holyfield is definetely the worst decision in the last 10 years, man i watch it over and over, and there is no way holyfield won a gingle round.
Dela Hoya VS Tito - I thoght dela hoya won that fight convincingly, yeah he only rallied at the end of rounds, but he still won the fight i feel.
Dela Hoya VS Mosely 2 - while i agree with the judges on the first fight, man they got it wrong in the second, dela hoya whooped mosely no doubt.
I agree completely, especially with the De La Hoya fight. No matter how many times i watch it i still cannot give the decision to Mosley. I don't know what the judges where seeing.
mosely de la hoya was all about money and who stood to be hurt more by the loss, mosely hadnt won a fight for 2 years and needed that win to stay a draw, oscar as we know is a draw anyway.
thats why they scored it for mosely plain and simple.
money.
mind you what comes round goes round, Felix Sturm anyone?
Dark Destroyer 10-12-2004, 10:50 AM mosely de la hoya was all about money and who stood to be hurt more by the loss, mosely hadnt won a fight for 2 years and needed that win to stay a draw, oscar as we know is a draw anyway.
thats why they scored it for mosely plain and simple.
money.
mind you what comes round goes round, Felix Sturm anyone?
Yeah i have to admit that i was one of the people who scored that for Sturm but only by a few points. That jab of his was really effective and accurate. Oscar was doing his flourry thing but alot of his punches were landing on the arms of Sturm for which i cannot give too many points for from a judging angle. I may be a harsh judge but Sturm was the more on target and controlled.
I was so upset when they gave the decision to Mosley, money shouldn't rule an obvious victory but i guess the it does when you view the Sturm fight. :rolleyes:
LuKahnLi 10-12-2004, 10:57 AM 3 Worst Decisions in the last 10 Years......
1-Holyfield to fight on after getting beat by Toney.
2-John Ruiz lacing up gloves after getting KO'd by Tua.
3-Freitas to hire Oscar Suarez as his trainer....cuz we all know what a great job Suarez did with Hamed.
anthetamine 10-12-2004, 11:00 AM I dont know how anyone can say lewis holyfield 2
i think lewis won both of the fights convincingly... you must be american to think lewsi lost the second one
first one wasnt even close second one was close, still gave it to lewis by 2 but hey Im a big lewis fan so cant begrudge and Evander fans for calling it.
the first fight was such an injustice and so huge was the outcry that if there was any doubt it had to go in Lennox favour though, ill say that much.
AlexanderTheGreat 10-12-2004, 01:02 PM taylor - DLH
DLH - Mosley 2
|