Well after stopping Spinks how does he rank? What's next for Spinks? Do you think Judah will give him another shot or do you think he will only welcome challenges from big name fighters now?

judah will give spinks a rematch but i dont think spinks will want it so soon.....judah ranks top 10 since cory was top 5 for some

i think judah jumps over corrales and the marques brothers. id say judah is 7 or 8th on the list

mayb 9 or 10
i wudnt consider him a top 10 but he a good fighter

Judah doesn't make top ten quite yet. He's definitely top 15 though!

I have him in the top 10 probably 8 or 9.

Judah doesn't make top ten quite yet. He's definitely top 15 though!

Yeah Judah isn't top 10 yet, but he's close

I don't think the rematch should be anytime soon, zab should go for a big name fight with DLH or mosely, strike while the iron is hot. I really don't think he should mess with Zoo even though in my view he was holding his own during the first few rounds.

Zab isn't quite in the top 10 yet but a few more wins over some name opponents he not only has the chance to be in the top 10 but he has the chance to be #1.

I really don't think he should mess with Zoo even though in my view he was holding his own during the first few rounds.

First few rounds? He was KTFO in the 2nd!!!

He doesn't rank. The guy has had 1 decent win and thatw as over a very vunerable champion in Spinks. Can you name me Zab Judah's second best win?...thats what I thought.

and no one on the planet who knows anything about boxing or is not taking money had Spinks top 5 p4p.

i say nine... but if he gets a rematch with... kostya... and win... which i think he will.. he'll be rank higher...

He doesn't rank. The guy has had 1 decent win and thatw as over a very vunerable champion in Spinks. Can you name me Zab Judah's second best win?...thats what I thought.

and no one on the planet who knows anything about boxing or is not taking money had Spinks top 5 p4p.

Agree 100%.

Judah is tough if he puts his mind to it i think he could beat Zoo i rematch. That would put him at like #3 or #4 on the pvp list.

I think he belongs at least 8 or 9 after that win, if not higher.

Judah doesn't make top ten quite yet. He's definitely top 15 though!

i agree. maybe 12th.

i think judah is top ten because he beat a top ten fighter in spinks.i had spinks 7th on my list before the fight here is my past and persent lists before and after the fight

pbf/ pbf
hopkins/ hopkins
zoo/ zoo
mab/ mab
pac/ pac
morales/ morales
spinks/ jmm
jmm/ judah
corrales/ corrales
rafeal marquez / spinks

i think judah is top ten because he beat a top ten fighter in spinks.i had spinks 7th on my list before the fight here is my past and persent lists before and after the fight

pbf/ pbf
hopkins/ hopkins
zoo/ zoo
mab/ mab
pac/ pac
morales/ morales
spinks/ jmm
jmm/ judah
corrales/ corrales
rafeal marquez / spinks


What about James Toney? Doesn't he make it on anywhere?

i say you can't really rate him yet, he has to fight p4p guy to gain that status, and win. spinks is no p4p fighter, the only one zab has fought, took him out. he has potential, but zab also has a suspect chin. when he starts taking out the bigger named guys, and guys with a bigger punch, then you can throw his name on p4p list. until then you got to put him on the outside of the list and watch to see what he does....

i think judah is top ten because he beat a top ten fighter in spinks.i had spinks 7th on my list before the fight here is my past and persent lists before and after the fight

pbf/ pbf
hopkins/ hopkins
zoo/ zoo
mab/ mab
pac/ pac
morales/ morales
spinks/ jmm
jmm/ judah
corrales/ corrales
rafeal marquez / spinks
you got almost everybody who has a belt, theres a few good names here but too many on the list, some of these guys need more career defining fights, but that's my opinion, and that aint much....so have a good one ...

He doesn't rank. The guy has had 1 decent win and thatw as over a very vunerable champion in Spinks. Can you name me Zab Judah's second best win?...thats what I thought.

and no one on the planet who knows anything about boxing or is not taking money had Spinks top 5 p4p.
Exactly. His second best win would probably have to be Chop-Chop, but that's the extent of his wins against anyone B-level and above.

I considered Spinks a paper champion because, in my view, he lost to Mayorga and to Zab the first time around. Spinks was 15 on my list and I'd be happy to put Zab in that spot but not one position higher.

i say nine... but if he gets a rematch with... kostya... and win... which i think he will.. he'll be rank higher...
i agree, rematch with kostya.
or a hell fight with dela hoya?

First off, who the **** puts Spinks in Top 5? Spinks was a Top 20 fighter, but no 5. Judah I think needs 1 more big win before he gets into the top 10. He's got the skills and speed to beat anyone at 147, if he can stay focused like he was Saturday. I think he takes the rematch, TKO's Spinks again, and then I would like to see him take on the winner of Margarito-Cintron. If he can be the fighter he was Saturday every day, the sky is the limit for Judah.

i cant see how off this performance anyone could pick zab over zoo... zab stil has one big weakness: a weak chin.... and sooner or later zoo will land on it....

zab judah wins over spinks last saturday.
give him a credit......men!
but not too much..

zab judah wins over spinks last saturday.
give him a credit......men!
but not too much..

I agree, i dont think you can rank top 10 P4P from one win.

Hopefuly we'll have good reason to rate Judah in the P4P's soon, even though he annoys the **** out of me i still respect his talents.