If they were both prime, at the same weight and had all their skills and attributes intact and they were both naturals at the weight of the fight, who would win?

good topic... both are evenly skilled offensively... but defensively, I give the nod to Pretty Boy... So overall I pick PBF

kk, come on ppl vote here

Who had more skills, PBF easily is the most skilled fighter I've ever seen & I've seen Robinson, Ali, Leonard etc..

When it comes to pure skills PBF & Leonard are the best I've seen.

Who had more skills, PBF easily is the most skilled fighter I've ever seen & I've seen Robinson, Ali, Leonard etc..

When it comes to pure skills PBF & Leonard are the best I've seen.

I agree with this

Jones was quicker in his prime than any man I've seen. He packed much more 1 punch power than Floyd too. Jones by late stoppage in an even fight.

Jones was a much better puncher to the head and body than Mayweather. People forget just how hard Jones hit at middleweight.

Jones was a much better puncher to the head and body than Mayweather. People forget just how hard Jones hit at middleweight.


Yeah he was almost on the same league as Mclellan, Jackson and Benn on punching power.

Jones was a much better puncher to the head and body than Mayweather. People forget just how hard Jones hit at middleweight.

preach! well said bro.

i wud also say RJJ, and by the poll results, its a RJJ win.

so far I'd have to say jones, but honestly I think PBF is going to get better than he is now. If that does indeed happen, PBF will get the nod.

Who had more skills, PBF easily is the most skilled fighter I've ever seen & I've seen Robinson, Ali, Leonard etc..

When it comes to pure skills PBF & Leonard are the best I've seen.

Robinson would kill Pretty Boy. PBF has great skills but hes no Robinson.

yeah Robinson would destroy Floyd.

I would choose PBF...Jones won fights with more style..but Mayweather is more skilled in boxing, at his prime..mayweather is untouchable! Would be a great fight tho!

Robinson would kill Pretty Boy. PBF has great skills but hes no Robinson.I put Robinson at the top of my list. He's the #1 P4P boxer of all time. But I've seen Robinson, his skills never impressed me as much as PBF, Leonard or Whiatker. Clearly PBF is the most skilled fighter I've ever seen.

Also for you saying Robinson will kill Floyd, is pretty much retarded. No one knows who would win these stupid fantasy fights. Most of the time we're all guessing out of our asses.