View Full Version : Arturo Gatti vs Miguel Cotto???


shane_mueller
03-12-2006, 11:01 PM
I was watching "In This Corner With Russ Anber" and he analyzing the 2 fighters and he said that there is a good possibility that we could see them fighting in the near future, if Gatti beats Baldomir.(which will happen)

If this fight does happen who do you think is favoured to win?

Brelampago
03-12-2006, 11:19 PM
Cotto will end Gattis career

Tony Blitz
03-12-2006, 11:22 PM
Cotto-Torres was a perfect example on how Gatti has a chance at this one. If Cotto plays it smart and sticks to boxing then he's obviously the winner of this one.

TheEvilSaint
03-12-2006, 11:25 PM
of the top guys from 140 to 147, cotto and baldy are the two guys that arturo can beat.

gatti by TKO.

Burzum_666
03-12-2006, 11:25 PM
I've said before I adore Gatti, one of my favorites, but this is another case where I say. Cotto would beat him up badly and stop him.

Brelampago
03-12-2006, 11:29 PM
Cotto-Torres was a perfect example on how Gatti has a chance at this one. If Cotto plays it smart and sticks to boxing then he's obviously the winner of this one.

How is Torres like Gatti? Maybe a better version. Torrres' counters and punches were quicker and sharpr than Gatti. Gatti is also wikid easy to hit. Cotto will jus pick him apart, bust his fragile face up,then stop him. Gatti just cantt hang w/ the elite,hes never beat an elite fighter. He can hang w/ some good fighters,but evrytime he steps up he gets put right back down. Cotto will end Gattis career,and make a big name for himself doing so. First Branco,then Paulie, then Gatti, the Italian killer Cotto.

Tony Blitz
03-12-2006, 11:33 PM
How is Torres like Gatti? Maybe a better version. Torrres' counters and punches were quicker and sharpr than Gatti. Gatti is also wikid easy to hit. Cotto will jus pick him apart, bust his fragile face up,then stop him. Gatti just cantt hang w/ the elite,hes never beat an elite fighter. He can hang w/ some good fighters,but evrytime he steps up he gets put right back down. Cotto will end Gattis career,and make a big name for himself doing so. First Branco,then Paulie, then Gatti, the Italian killer Cotto.
I'm not comparing them, I'm saying Cotto's disability to brawl with someone like Gatti would cost him the fight. Look at how he did against Torres when he tried brawling.

gattifan24
03-12-2006, 11:34 PM
I think Gatti would win. I like both fighters a lot but Arturo's problem usually comes from speed guys who can box. Miguel can box some for sure but the difference in speed won't be vast. Miguel is quicker but not by a a margin Gatti's power couldn't overcome. I'd pick Gatti by KO but either way I think it'd ba a FOY candidate and not likely at all to go 12

JDizzle79
03-12-2006, 11:36 PM
cotto needs to obviously fight a quality oppenent. I can't believe people buy his pay-per-views when he fights nobodys on short notice...he's over rated

TheEvilSaint
03-12-2006, 11:36 PM
I think Gatti would win. I like both fighters a lot but Arturo's problem usually comes from speed guys who can box. Miguel can box some for sure but the difference in speed won't be vast. Miguel is quicker but not by a a margin Gatti's power couldn't overcome. I'd pick Gatti by KO but either way I think it'd ba a FOY candidate and not likely at all to go 12
thats what i said about wlad/peter.

JDizzle79
03-12-2006, 11:37 PM
actually, its fighters that fight him on short notice and give him problems, let me correct myself

Brelampago
03-12-2006, 11:38 PM
I'm not comparing them, I'm saying Cotto's disability to brawl with someone like Gatti would cost him the fight. Look at how he did against Torres when he tried brawling.

Got ya, but Torres was much sharper w/ counters and much quicker than Gatti is,in my opinion at least. I think Cotto will put it on Gatti if they box or brawl, Gatti jus cant hang w/the elite. I wanna see Bojado vs Gatti.

Brelampago
03-12-2006, 11:47 PM
actually, its fighters that fight him on short notice and give him problems, let me correct myself

U forget Torrres was 28-0 26 KO's. He was Cotto's mandatory challenger and him and Cotto were scheduled to fight that December anyway,so he was already on his mind. Torres was fresh off a fight against Vazquez,a fight he won easily by KO,when Branco pulled outa the September fight,so Torres stepped in because he was in shape and they were gona fight anyway.Torres would give anybody in he top 10 hell.

USA4LIFE
03-12-2006, 11:51 PM
Gatti has his power and Cotto has that suspect chin. If Cotto boxes he can easily tear Gatti a new one but if he decides to exchange with Gatti he can eaisly be put to sleep. I'll pick Cotto on the fact that he will box gatti to death but if Gatti scores a KO I wouldn't be that surprised.

xcaret
03-12-2006, 11:51 PM
U forget Torrres was 28-0 26 KO's. He was Cotto's mandatory challenger and him and Cotto were scheduled to fight that December anyway,so he was already on his mind. Torres was fresh off a fight against Vazquez,a fight he won easily by KO,when Branco pulled outa the September fight,so Torres stepped in because he was in shape and they were gona fight anyway.Torres would give anybody in he top 10 hell.

People would love to see a rematch, i know i would :boxing:

USA4LIFE
03-12-2006, 11:55 PM
People would love to see a rematch, i know i would :boxing:

I would like to see that too but it isn't worth the risk IMO.

Roberto_Roldan_
03-13-2006, 12:21 AM
Thats a good fight for sure, but i would have to go with Cotto just cuz i think Gatti wouldnt be able to out box him or knock him out. Cotto goes very well to the body and that would affect Gatti i think. But thats just my opinion

machotime
03-13-2006, 11:08 AM
cotto needs to obviously fight a quality oppenent. I can't believe people buy his pay-per-views when he fights nobodys on short notice...he's over rated
Obviously you have not seen him fight. He has not had a PPV, secondly, he does not fight nobodies, unless you call Sosa, Ceballos, Bazan, N'dou, and Jukko "nobodies". I guess Mayweather is on the same boat, bc he too fought these fighters.

Emmanuel Steward said it at Cotto's last fight "Cotto has the most impressive 25(now 26) fight record in boxing"

machotime
03-13-2006, 11:10 AM
U forget Torrres was 28-0 26 KO's. He was Cotto's mandatory challenger and him and Cotto were scheduled to fight that December anyway,so he was already on his mind. Torres was fresh off a fight against Vazquez,a fight he won easily by KO,when Branco pulled outa the September fight,so Torres stepped in because he was in shape and they were gona fight anyway.Torres would give anybody in he top 10 hell.
I definately agree. Also, Torres will soon fight Juan Lazcano, and I truly believe that Torres will KO Lazcano.

TheEvilSaint
03-13-2006, 11:15 AM
I definately agree. Also, Torres will soon fight Juan Lazcano, and I truly believe that Torres will KO Lazcano.
i disagree. i think torres his helluva hard, but i dont think he'll KO lazcano.

lazcano by UD.

Oasis_Lad
03-13-2006, 11:18 AM
Gatti has his power and Cotto has that suspect chin. If Cotto boxes he can easily tear Gatti a new one but if he decides to exchange with Gatti he can eaisly be put to sleep. I'll pick Cotto on the fact that he will box gatti to death but if Gatti scores a KO I wouldn't be that surprised.

this is 100% correct if cotto boxes to the best of his ability
then my boy gatti is gonna get tore up
but if cotto at any point during the fight attempts to slug it out
then gatti ko's him

TheEvilSaint
03-13-2006, 11:20 AM
i would love for this fight to happen. but at this stage of his career, gatti cannot afford to lose another big fight, or any other fight.

but this is a big fight were gatti has a legit chance of winning.

machotime
03-13-2006, 11:22 AM
i disagree. i think torres his helluva hard, but i dont think he'll KO lazcano.

lazcano by UD.
I guess we will see, remember that Lazcano is a small 140 and he has never faced a 140 with the power of Torres.

Deeznuts
03-13-2006, 11:39 AM
Hopefully Cotto will stop fighting meaningless fights. I mean if he does fight Gatti and beats him, what will that prove? Gatti has alot to gain and Cotto has nothing. He needs to look past these C class fighters and start fighting some A class fighters.

MusclesMalone
03-13-2006, 11:51 AM
gatti is easy to tag. i think cotto's left hook will make gatti's face into mush. cotto by tko before the seventh.

machotime
03-13-2006, 11:51 AM
Hopefully Cotto will stop fighting meaningless fights. I mean if he does fight Gatti and beats him, what will that prove? Gatti has alot to gain and Cotto has nothing. He needs to look past these C class fighters and start fighting some A class fighters.
Like? Cotto is still kind of green and should not be fighting Mayweather. Hatton has not expressed intrest in Cotto, But Cotto has. Hatton's camp has stated, that "fights with Cotto and Mayweather are inevidable and will happen soon enough" but his daddy wants him to have several fights in the US before he fights Mayweather or COtto. Also, Cotto has 26fights not 40. He has the best 26 fight resume in boxing. Give the guy credit for fighting solid opposition.

machotime
03-13-2006, 11:59 AM
Hopefully Cotto will stop fighting meaningless fights. I mean if he does fight Gatti and beats him, what will that prove? Gatti has alot to gain and Cotto has nothing. He needs to look past these C class fighters and start fighting some A class fighters.
I guess you define meaningless fights as fights with top contenders, and mandatory challengers? :(

baya
03-13-2006, 12:08 PM
Cotto P U N I S H E S gatti and ends his career. like pbf says, EASY WORK. :cool:

simply put, gatti could never win a fight w/ cotto in the same ring, too much talent and skill. he'd bust up gatti's right side all day and stay on the outside for the first half, then when gatti's favoring his body and going for the kill like he does, he gets caught upstairs, BAM, miguelito lowers the hammer. once again, easy work.

borikua
03-13-2006, 12:33 PM
That would be great fight for Cotto to debut at 147...

Zab Super Judah
03-13-2006, 12:43 PM
I was watching "In This Corner With Russ Anber" and he analyzing the 2 fighters and he said that there is a good possibility that we could see them fighting in the near future, if Gatti beats Baldomir.(which will happen)

If this fight does happen who do you think is favoured to win?

Gatti has a chance to definitely hurt cotto. But believe me Gatti wont be able to take Cotto's shots. Cotto has faster and possibly harder shots. I can see Gatti in a close fight then taking a beating later on with buddy mcgirt stopping the fight

USA4LIFE
03-13-2006, 01:27 PM
i would love for this fight to happen. but at this stage of his career, gatti cannot afford to lose another big fight, or any other fight.

but this is a big fight were gatti has a legit chance of winning.

If this fight does happen and Gatti does lose it would still be a big pay day for him to go out on IMO.

Deeznuts
03-13-2006, 01:28 PM
Like? Cotto is still kind of green and should not be fighting Mayweather. Hatton has not expressed intrest in Cotto, But Cotto has. Hatton's camp has stated, that "fights with Cotto and Mayweather are inevidable and will happen soon enough" but his daddy wants him to have several fights in the US before he fights Mayweather or COtto. Also, Cotto has 26fights not 40. He has the best 26 fight resume in boxing. Give the guy credit for fighting solid opposition.

I give Cotto credit for his resume but he is fighting similar opposition. Guys who struggle against champions. To answer your question other than Hatton and Mayweather he could fight: Corrales, Castillo, Margarito, I wouldn't mind seeing him fight Joel Julio or even Kermit Cintron. But you never hear anyone mention any of those names. After Maussa got the belt from Harris, he showed interest in a rematch. And this Paul guy why in the hell is he fighting him?

USA4LIFE
03-13-2006, 01:31 PM
I give Cotto credit for his resume but he is fighting similar opposition. Guys who struggle against champions. To answer your question other than Hatton and Mayweather he could fight: Corrales, Castillo, Margarito, I wouldn't mind seeing him fight Joel Julio or even Kermit Cintron. But you never hear anyone mention any of those names. After Maussa got the belt from Harris, he showed interest in a rematch. And this Paul guy why in the hell is he fighting him?

Like what macho stated before, he has only 26 fights, you'll see him fight superstars soon enough lol.

shane_mueller
03-13-2006, 09:04 PM
I'd put my money on Gatti in this fight, simply because i think he has more power, can take a huge beating and still come out swinging, and its about time cotto loses. Sure Cotto can box but if he gets in close with Gatti, hes over.

Floydmayweather
03-13-2006, 10:39 PM
Cotto will crush Gatti box him early and then bust him up.

oldgringo
03-13-2006, 11:00 PM
Cotto busts up Gatti and stops him in the mid-late rounds. He's better at pretty much every facet in the game.

USA, nice sig...Equilibrium was a good movie.

.::EnRiQuE::.
03-14-2006, 12:26 AM
Gatti has his power and Cotto has that suspect chin. If Cotto boxes he can easily tear Gatti a new one but if he decides to exchange with Gatti he can eaisly be put to sleep. I'll pick Cotto on the fact that he will box gatti to death but if Gatti scores a KO I wouldn't be that surprised.
i completely agreee with you....im at the same point you are...if cotto boxes smart he wins, if he stands in there gets put to sleep

machotime
03-14-2006, 07:27 AM
I give Cotto credit for his resume but he is fighting similar opposition. Guys who struggle against champions. To answer your question other than Hatton and Mayweather he could fight: Corrales, Castillo, Margarito, I wouldn't mind seeing him fight Joel Julio or even Kermit Cintron. But you never hear anyone mention any of those names. After Maussa got the belt from Harris, he showed interest in a rematch. And this Paul guy why in the hell is he fighting him?
None of these are in Cotto's weight Class. Cotto cannot afford to drop weight, although he may go up to 147. And for the Cotto/Castillo fight, that fight was going to happen after Castillo/Corrales III, it would have been set for June, but the Castillo/Corrales fight was delayed and other plans had to be made.

Ranger2408
03-14-2006, 09:27 AM
Gatti couldn't even KO branco for crying out loud
GATTI IS A BUM :D

Cotto brawls he wins,
Cotto boxes he wins,

Gatti has no chance he is slow, has overrated power because he comes in at 160 and he can't box to save his life.

machotime
03-14-2006, 09:33 AM
Gatti couldn't even KO branco for crying out loud
GATTI IS A BUM :D

Cotto brawls he wins,
Cotto boxes he wins,

Gatti has no chance he is slow, has overrated power because he comes in at 160 and he can't box to save his life.
I wouldn't go to the extent of saying that Gatti is a bum, he is a fighter that has power and has heart, the difference between him and Cotto is that Cotto has TALENT and can box. Gatti brawls, and when someone uses a jab against him, he cant seem to get out of the way. I think that Gatti has a punchers chance, but that chance is slim. Cotto will stop Gatti, he would probably make Gatti's face a mess.

Deeznuts
03-14-2006, 10:10 AM
None of these are in Cotto's weight Class Neither is Gatti or Mayweather.

machotime
03-14-2006, 10:26 AM
Neither is Gatti or Mayweather.
Gatti and Mayweather have had recent fights at 140. I don't think that Margarito or Cintron have had a fight at 140. Corrales has not expressed interest in fighting at 140, Castillo has and Cotto/Castillo was well on its way until Corrales was hurt. If Cotto moves to 147 which he will, his best bet is to fight a small 147 like Gatti, not a huge 147 like Margarito or Cintron. Margarito looks like a middleweight for God sakes.

Undefeated
03-14-2006, 10:40 AM
For Cotto moving up to 147 then fighting Margarito as his first fight or so is stupid. Margarito is huge and has had many fights there. Gatti on the other hand would be a good fight,as for Castillo. I hope a Cotto Vs Castillo Happens by the end of this year. As for Mayweather i don't know. We will see who he wants to fight after April 8 vs Judah. That fight is stupid! No need for that fight. Mayweather could've fought some one better!

Ranger2408
03-14-2006, 03:57 PM
Obviously you have not seen him fight. He has not had a PPV, secondly, he does not fight nobodies, unless you call Sosa, Ceballos, Bazan, N'dou, and Jukko "nobodies". I guess Mayweather is on the same boat, bc he too fought these fighters.

Emmanuel Steward said it at Cotto's last fight "Cotto has the most impressive 25(now 26) fight record in boxing"He fought on PPvs though i don't know if you mean he is the headliner or not, the juuko fight was definately a PPV i have every single cotto fight on my pc bar one early very hard to find one.

Undefeated
03-14-2006, 04:01 PM
He fought on PPvs though i don't know if you mean he is the headliner or not, the juuko fight was definately a PPV i have every single cotto fight on my pc bar one early very hard to find one.


You just got 100% of my attention! You got almost every Cotto fight?! :eek:


Upload Cotto Vs Bailey... can you? If you can just PM when ever iight...

Or if not Cotto Vs Juuko

machotime
03-14-2006, 04:04 PM
He fought on PPvs though i don't know if you mean he is the headliner or not, the juuko fight was definately a PPV i have every single cotto fight on my pc bar one early very hard to find one.
I assumed that headlining PPV was what it meant, that is why I responded to it.