View Full Version : Out of curiousity why are Indians referring to themselves as Asians?


BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:08 PM
The term "Asian" doesnt say anything about their race at all as Indians are very different from Chinese, Japanese, Filipino, etc. It's a vague term like saying my race is American.

PS: Objects, inanimate things are oriental, not people. You will get slapped if you call someone in China town oriental for real.

RAESAAD
09-21-2005, 12:09 PM
India in in Asia.American Indians do not refer to themselves as Asian or should not anyway.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:11 PM
Yes, but they put their call themselves Asian as in race. Thats like saying Corrie Sanders is an African American (if he had US citizenship).

RAESAAD
09-21-2005, 12:15 PM
Yes, but they put their call themselves Asian as in race. Thats like saying Corrie Sanders is an African American (if he had US citizenship).
I have never heard Indians refer to themselves as such...I have a friend from India and he calls himself Indian.Corrie Sanders is S.African and would not be considered African American.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:18 PM
Yeah Raesaad, we're talking about America. Yes Indian Americans call themselves Indians. But in Europe they call themselves Asian.

And I know a white Gambian doing optical engineering here that puts down African American as his race.
I have never heard Indians refer to themselves as such...I have a friend from India and he calls himself Indian.Corrie Sanders is S.African and would not be considered African American.

RAESAAD
09-21-2005, 12:19 PM
Yeah Raesaad, we're talking about America. Yes Indian Americans call themselves Indians. But in Europe they call themselves Asian.

And I know a white Gambian doing optical engineering here that puts down African American as his race.
Hmmmmmm I have no ****ing idea then.

jabsRstiff
09-21-2005, 12:21 PM
Someone....

Desrcibe what it takes for someone to be "Asian" ?

medium-deek
09-21-2005, 12:21 PM
And I know a white Gambian doing optical engineering here that puts down African American as his race.

Now thats weird.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:22 PM
John Salley has a white friend that does that too. I hear him talk about it on The Best Damned Sports Show.
Now thats weird.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:23 PM
Im talking about physical/outter appearance. The biggest giveaway obviously are the eyes. The term Asian in terms of geography is incorrect usage, because I guess Filipinos aren't Asian since their series of islands are NOT apart of the Asian continent.
Someone....

Desrcibe what it takes for someone to be "Asian" ?

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 12:24 PM
Every American is African-American if you want to go back far enough...unless you're one of them folks who doesn't believe in evolution.

Mr. Beelzebub
09-21-2005, 12:25 PM
Very quickly sir. Racial clasification and determination are closely tied to a country's history and culture. In latin America for example, "lighter" people are considered white. In Brazil, a bi-racial person is considered to be white if his complexion fits what is referred to as such.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:26 PM
Yes, I believe in evolution and the "Out of Africa" theory. The Great Rift Valley in Kenya/Tanzania is where humans first appeared not the Garden of Eden (present day Iraq).
Every American is African-American if you want to go back far enough...unless you're one of them folks who doesn't believe in evolution.

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 12:29 PM
Yes, I believe in evolution and the "Out of Africa" theory. The Great Rift Valley in Kenya/Tanzania is where humans first appeared not the Garden of Eden (present day Iraq).

I think half the reason some people don't believe in evolution is because they don't want to believe that they came from black people. Just a thought.

btw the reason that all the killer viruses (AIDS, Ebola, etc.) come from the Rift Valley area is because they evolved along with us. You always evolve alongside your most natural predators because they can evolve and adapt right along with you. Of course you also adapt so to feed off of the environment as well. It's part of the reason why Africa is both the most suitable and most hostile environment for us to live in.

Lol999
09-21-2005, 12:42 PM
I think the term Asian is a generic term to describe people of a similar appearance and geographic origin. Certainly within this description you get pride in their origin, i.e. Indian, Pakistani etc. I don't think there's anything derogatory in doing this, if there were then I'm sure the folks it affects would have told us by now.

Lol

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 12:45 PM
Also, Indian and Pakistani are the same thing. Just because Britian seperated part of India in the 50s and created Pakistan doesnt mean they automatically created a new race (Pakistanis).

PBDS
09-21-2005, 12:48 PM
I think half the reason some people don't believe in evolution is because they don't want to believe that they came from black people. Just a thought.

btw the reason that all the killer viruses (AIDS, Ebola, etc.) come from the Rift Valley area is because they evolved along with us. You always evolve alongside your most natural predators because they can evolve and adapt right along with you. Of course you also adapt so to feed off of the environment as well. It's part of the reason why Africa is both the most suitable and most hostile environment for us to live in.


.....Yeah but if that particular evolutionary theory is true wouldn't I be able to dance and sing like Mr. Bojangles? :)

hectari
09-21-2005, 12:58 PM
It goes with ignorance. Racism is more like LOOKISM.Russians, siberians, ukrainians, finish all of them are eurasian. Alot of them have mongol blood it just doesnt show as much because of evololution. you guys heard of the tokarians? they were light skined light eyed red haired people of asia from long ago. They also had european looking people in japan in fact long long ago they were the original habitats of the island they were called the AINU I think.

hectari
09-21-2005, 12:58 PM
The Ainu are a people with a cultural and racial background which is different from that of the ethnic Japanese. They have been populating Hokkaido, northern Tohoku, the Kurile Islands and Sakhalin, but today only a small population remains mainly in Hokkaido.

According to one of several theories, the Ainu are descendants of Mongoloid migrants who entered the Japanese islands before the Jomon period. They were later displaced and assimilated, when the ethnic Japanese expanded their territory northernwards.

In the Meiji Period (1868-1912), the Ainu received the status of "former aboriginals", but suffered under official discrimination for some years. In 1997, a new law was passed which provides funds for the research and promotion of Ainu culture.

PBDS
09-21-2005, 01:03 PM
The Ainu are a people with a cultural and racial background which is different from that of the ethnic Japanese. They have been populating Hokkaido, northern Tohoku, the Kurile Islands and Sakhalin, but today only a small population remains mainly in Hokkaido.

According to one of several theories, the Ainu are descendants of Mongoloid migrants who entered the Japanese islands before the Jomon period. They were later displaced and assimilated, when the ethnic Japanese expanded their territory northernwards.

In the Meiji Period (1868-1912), the Ainu received the status of "former aboriginals", but suffered under official discrimination for some years. In 1997, a new law was passed which provides funds for the research and promotion of Ainu culture.


....Hectari with a very infomative post. Good info.

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:04 PM
Also, Indian and Pakistani are the same thing. Just because Britian seperated part of India in the 50s and created Pakistan doesnt mean they automatically created a new race (Pakistanis).

Ok, they are not the same thing. Thats like saying Americans and Canadians are the same thing.

Where i live there arent many people from China Japan...
So when we refer to somone as Asian, we mean somone who looks Indian, Pakistani e.t.c

SO, in the uk, most Indian Pakistani or Bangladeshi people would be referd to as ASIAN.

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 01:10 PM
.....Yeah but if that particular evolutionary theory is true wouldn't I be able to dance and sing like Mr. Bojangles? :)

It's in your genes somewhere...just move your feet and see what happens, you never know :) .

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 01:11 PM
The Ainu are a people with a cultural and racial background which is different from that of the ethnic Japanese. They have been populating Hokkaido, northern Tohoku, the Kurile Islands and Sakhalin, but today only a small population remains mainly in Hokkaido.

According to one of several theories, the Ainu are descendants of Mongoloid migrants who entered the Japanese islands before the Jomon period. They were later displaced and assimilated, when the ethnic Japanese expanded their territory northernwards.

In the Meiji Period (1868-1912), the Ainu received the status of "former aboriginals", but suffered under official discrimination for some years. In 1997, a new law was passed which provides funds for the research and promotion of Ainu culture.

Yes, cool info...is it true that the Ainu still aren't allowed to vote?

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 01:17 PM
They are the same. Britain didnt make two races 50 years ago.
Ok, they are not the same thing. Thats like saying Americans and Canadians are the same thing.

Where i live there arent many people from China Japan...
So when we refer to somone as Asian, we mean somone who looks Indian, Pakistani e.t.c

SO, in the uk, most Indian Pakistani or Bangladeshi people would be referd to as ASIAN.

medium-deek
09-21-2005, 01:20 PM
Ok, they are not the same thing. Thats like saying Americans and Canadians are the same thing.

Where i live there arent many people from China Japan...
So when we refer to somone as Asian, we mean somone who looks Indian, Pakistani e.t.c

SO, in the uk, most Indian Pakistani or Bangladeshi people would be referd to as ASIAN.

Coooooooorrreeeecccct!!!

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:25 PM
They are the same. Britain didnt make two races 50 years ago.

I understand that.

But the fact is somone from Pakistan is Pakistani!!!

What should they refer to themselves as?? INDIAN??????

lol

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 01:26 PM
Because they were Indians before britain came.

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 01:28 PM
I have a pakistani friend that was pissed when I asked if he was Indian. **** he sure isnt Arab. He kept referring to Arabs and his people as "we" and so it makes me think that he wants to be or identifies with Arabs more than indians.

hectari
09-21-2005, 01:29 PM
Yes, cool info...is it true that the Ainu still aren't allowed to vote?


I am not sure but at one point they were looked down on, like the aborigines of australia. Both are indigenous to their lands, it is what happens when people take over other lands and invade they spit upon those people. Example Native AMericans being spat on by the british pilgrims, aboriginies by the shipped in brtish Criminals who were sent their, and the tibetians with the chinese, and the ainu with the japanese, but japanese dont wanna admit they are closley related to koreans. It is similar to pakistanis, and indians how they are both the same but are considered different.

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 01:29 PM
Because they were Indians before britain came.

Yes, it's a difference in religion. Besides, a lot of the people that lived in Pakistan now lived in India before the partition, and only moved there because it matched their religion (and they were forced to...millions possibly died in these mass migrations).

Bombardier
09-21-2005, 01:31 PM
I am not sure but at one point they were looked down on, like the aborigines of australia. Both are indigenous to their lands, it is what happens when people take over other lands and invade they spit upon those people. Example Native AMericans being spat on by the british pilgrims, aboriginies by the shipped in brtish Criminals who were sent their, and the tibetians with the chinese, and the ainu with the japanese, but japanese dont wanna admit they are closley related to koreans. It is similar to pakistanis, and indians how they are both the same but are considered different.

The treatmeant of the abroigines and North (and South) American natives in the 19th century was shameful. I can understand more people in the 1500s not knowing any better but by this point people were more or less fully away of what they were doing.

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:32 PM
I have a pakistani friend that was pissed when I asked if he was Indian. **** he sure isnt Arab. He kept referring to Arabs and his people as "we" and so it makes me think that he wants to be or identifies with Arabs more than indians.

HE IS PAKISTANI!!!!!!!!!! :eek:

It doesnt matter when a country was divided , the fact is they are now seperate countries.

Like i said, America and Canada. The same??

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 01:32 PM
The people yes, if you asked that 50 years after American/Canadian border was demarcated.

hectari
09-21-2005, 01:33 PM
....Hectari with a very infomative post. Good info.


Thanks man, ya orginal japanese inhabitants were caucasian looking with long noses and features they got there or migrated thier similar to how the native americans got to america through that frozing ice bridge. I will look fo some pictures but they have more descriptions they looked mediteranean like italians and persian.

medium-deek
09-21-2005, 01:35 PM
I have a pakistani friend that was pissed when I asked if he was Indian. **** he sure isnt Arab. He kept referring to Arabs and his people as "we" and so it makes me think that he wants to be or identifies with Arabs more than indians.

I shouldn't be surprised he was pissed considering India and Pakistan have fought three wars since Independence.

hectari
09-21-2005, 01:35 PM
The treatmeant of the abroigines and North (and South) American natives in the 19th century was shameful. I can understand more people in the 1500s not knowing any better but by this point people were more or less fully away of what they were doing.


ya you have to agree though isnt it quite ironic the name AMERICA and AMERICAN is linked with a white person but the name is not of germanic orgin. South americans are not considered americans ? hahaah isnt that more funny. People say all american and they think white guy.

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:37 PM
The people yes, if you asked that 50 years after American/Canadian border was demarcated.

What would you call a person from Pakistan?

BLOODSHED
09-21-2005, 01:39 PM
He did say he was Indian but acted like I asked if he was gay when I asked if he was Indian.

Person from Pakistan:
Nationality:Pakistani Race:Indian.
What would you call a person from Pakistan?

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:48 PM
He did say he was Indian but acted like I asked if he was gay when I asked if he was Indian.

Person from Pakistan:
Nationality:Pakistani Race:Indian.

Geez, ur just trying to be difficult.

I would call my ethnic origin as Anglo Indian, and my nationality would be British.

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 01:50 PM
He did say he was Indian but acted like I asked if he was gay when I asked if he was Indian.

Person from Pakistan:
Nationality:Pakistani Race:Indian.

Also, as some people from Pakistan would be offended by being called Indian. You would probably be wise just to call somone from Pakistan a Pakistani. Right? Right!

Lol999
09-21-2005, 02:03 PM
Ever watch East Is East? The Pakistani father is incensed that the doctor treating his son might be Indian!

Lol

Bubba Chunday
09-21-2005, 02:05 PM
Ever watch East Is East? The Pakistani father is incensed that the doctor treating his son might be Indian!

Lol

i think i taped over it. Anygood?

PBDS
09-21-2005, 02:19 PM
Also, as some people from Pakistan would be offended by being called Indian. You would probably be wise just to call somone from Pakistan a Pakistani. Right? Right!


...This is a question for Riz. He is Pakistani in his view but he has Indian and Pakistani parents and grandparents. Actually he is Canadian since birth so he is really neither.

Sweat
09-21-2005, 02:45 PM
Wow.. did u guys pay attention to your geography teacher when you were in 8th grade?? jeez..

Pakistan and India are part of Asia. Those countries are in south Asia. So they are considered Asians. If they dont consider themselves as Asians then who gives a ****. But they are still part of Asia. Just like US and Canada. They are in the continent called North America so they are considered as North Americans. Same as the hispanics.. I'm talking about Mexicans, Brazillians, Argentinians etc.. They are are also Americans but they are South Americans because thats what their continent is called.

And Filipinos are also Asians because the country is in the southeastern part of Asia. But they can also be considered as Pacific Islanders.

boxstarr
09-21-2005, 02:45 PM
indians and pakistanis are completely different

they even look different

also...you cant define someone as asians by the eyes

you are so racist its untrue

Sweat
09-21-2005, 02:46 PM
Oh ya, if youre talking about the Indians(Native Americans) well, they came from Asia right? so they can be considered as Asians too.

Sweat
09-21-2005, 02:49 PM
indians and pakistanis are completely different

they even look different

also...you cant define someone as asians by the eyes

you are so racist its untrue

WAT THE HELL... so u mean, only cheenks are considered Asians? then what do u call the people in India then?? I mean, u do know that its part of Asia right??

hectari
09-21-2005, 03:18 PM
indians and pakistanis are completely different

they even look different

also...you cant define someone as asians by the eyes

you are so racist its untrue


Are you ignorant? they are not completely different in fact genetecially they are the same! they are only seperated by religion. Go search it up.They also have a fued they dont like each other not all but alot of **** dont like indians.

Martin (Top Knowledge)
09-21-2005, 04:20 PM
Im talking about physical/outter appearance. The biggest giveaway obviously are the eyes. The term Asian in terms of geography is incorrect usage, because I guess Filipinos aren't Asian since their series of islands are NOT apart of the Asian continent.
Yes they are... Phillipines is an Asian country, it's made up of many islands... Because it's in Asia! As is India, as is China, as are the countries in the Middle-East.

What's so hard to understand???... I'm European because I live In Europe....

.::EnRiQuE::.
09-21-2005, 04:48 PM
Im talking about physical/outter appearance. The biggest giveaway obviously are the eyes. The term Asian in terms of geography is incorrect usage, because I guess Filipinos aren't Asian since their series of islands are NOT apart of the Asian continent.
its a part of the continent of Asia...just not a part of the mainland...sort of like hawaii

hectari
09-21-2005, 04:55 PM
its a part of the continent of Asia...just not a part of the mainland...sort of like hawaii


That whole island area is tricky. you got the fiji, the somoans, tonga, phillipines, indonesia.... and so forth. but they are all different but all located near asia at the same time this geography stuff just is plain confusing. I give props to who ever has to cover the census over their they got a tough ass job hahaah.

Lol999
09-21-2005, 05:01 PM
i think i taped over it. Anygood?

Really good, especially if you can remember the '70's, which I can! I think you can get it on DVD for about £5 now.

Lol

RAESAAD
09-21-2005, 05:01 PM
I shouldn't be surprised he was pissed considering India and Pakistan have fought three wars since Independence.
True indeed Pakastanis and Indians hate each other did'nt he watch Barbershop.That is what is so ****ed up about the middleeast is alot of them hate each other and the rest of the world.Too much religeous conflict.I mean just look at Iraq 3 different beliefs hating each other in one country.STOP THE HATE PEOPLE......Nuttin But Love.

boxstarr
09-22-2005, 04:05 PM
you are all stupid

im saying....the eyes arent what you judge asians by

indians pakistanis bangladeshis sri lankans etc are all called asians

also...if you look at indians and pakistanis its easy to tell the difference

pakistanis tend to be much fairer

i can even tell the difference between tamil, gujarati, pakistani, bengali, punjabi etc etc etc

ignorant fools

dont tell me you right when you aint

being wrong makes you look stupid