View Full Version : james toney fighter of the year 2003


everlast99
09-05-2005, 12:29 PM
anyone think this belongs to jones?..i know toney had a big win over jirov and an over the top holyfield..but jones made ruis look like a kid trying to get his candy back...and he showed his heart for the first time against antonio tarver

ZABJUDAH#1P4P
09-05-2005, 12:35 PM
anyone think this belongs to jones?..i know toney had a big win over jirov and an over the top holyfield..but jones made ruis look like a kid trying to get his candy back...and he showed his heart for the first time against antonio tarver


as much as i wish i could say jones since i do like him better than toney. i love toney to so dont get me wrong.

anyway toney dominated a better heavyweight in holyfield and knocked him out. also toney dominated jirov, better than jones dominated tarver.

the jones tarver fight wasnt as close as people say i had it 9-3 for jones, and the closest i could possibly see was 8-4.

tarver is a lot better than jirov though but never the less toney did dominate jirov and knocked him down.

i was glad to see toney get it, i think thats the first time the fighter i thought deserved it actually won it.

riz
09-05-2005, 12:57 PM
sorry but holfyeild wasn't the better heavyweight. he was finished.... ruiz was at least still winning fights.
toney dominated jirov, IMO he won because of the last round
and IMO tarver won at least 5 roudns man.

i dont think toney deserved it all all man...
who won the one for 2004?

ZABJUDAH#1P4P
09-05-2005, 01:01 PM
sorry but holfyeild wasn't the better heavyweight. he was finished.... ruiz was at least still winning fights.
toney dominated jirov, IMO he won because of the last round
and IMO tarver won at least 5 roudns man.

i dont think toney deserved it all all man...
who won the one for 2004?

Glen johnson who got a gift against tarver.

everlast99
09-05-2005, 01:11 PM
i think johnson deserved the 2004

DiegoFuego
09-05-2005, 02:24 PM
Jones got his ass beat up by Tarver in November of 2003. He won a fight against an outclasses opponent and arguably drew with a guy. No way Jones gets it over Toney.

DiegoFuego
09-05-2005, 02:25 PM
Corrales should have got 2004, but Johnson did with his bs split decision over Tarver. Give me a break

ZABJUDAH#1P4P
09-05-2005, 02:36 PM
Corrales should have got 2004, but Johnson did with his bs split decision over Tarver. Give me a break

i thought casamayor would have been a good choice seeing how he really beat chico and castillo.